The Impossible Disappearance Of Dorothy Arnold

The Impossible Disappearance Of Dorothy Arnold

Show Video

This. Week on a special episode of BuzzFeed unsolved, we investigate, the unexplained, disappearance of New York heiress Dorothy Arnold in honor of the upcoming CW. Show Nancy, Drew The CW's, new series Nancy Drew Wednesday's this fall is a dark and edgy update, of the classic book series featuring the titular teen detective, in a supernatural, tinged, mystery drama what's. Dorothy got to do with old. Nance in the show Nancy. Drew is tasked, with finding a missing. Socialite. So I'd, love to be an heiress I. Know. She's probably gonna disappear, or something so you want to be a trust fund baby I'd like someone to give me a lot of money for doing nothing and, then you want to disappear but I was yes I want, to get. A lot of money and then vanish from the face of the earth and I'd love for you to disappear let's. Get into it yeah, tales, of the missing wealthy have always captivated, the public's imagination and, today, we're looking into one such case that's more than a hundred years old, Dorothy, Arnold, Dorothy, Harriet Camille Arnold, was the daughter of Mary Parks Arnold and wilty perfume, importer, Frances rose Arnold, as far as anybody knew she'd had a happy home life cool to be a perfume. Importer, I'd. Love to be that what, would your fragrance be what was it what would the name be, mmm. It'd. Be musky I know that okay for a second I thought your fragrance name was gonna be just a chipmunk like chipmunk noises. Did. You imagine if someone said oh that's a lovely scent what is that. Okay. I'll, see you later on the, morning of December 12 1910. The 25, year old left her family home in the Upper East Side of Manhattan and told, her mother she was heading downtown to, buy an evening dress, according. To the New York Times when mrs. Arnold offered to accompany her daughter Dorothy, said no quote, when I find the gown I want I will telephone you and you can come down and see it end quote I'll tell you what she sounds like an heiress pretty curt yeah, with your mother how about when, I find, the, gown, I want, maybe. I'll talk to you then how. About your tag when, I need the funds I'll call you how about that yeah how do you think this lady's buying gowns I mean if she's buying an evening down you would assume she's buying an afternoon, gown in a morning down maybe even a sleepy time gown that's right her family believed that when she left at 11:30, a.m. she, had as much as $30.

In Her purse which, in today's dollars would be more than 750, dollars, holy moly that's a lot of key yeah, a lot of key 30 bucks going, that far in 1910, I don't even have 750, dollars in my bank account I've never had 750. Dollars in my pocket I rarely, have had thirty dollars in my pocket well I don't really carry cash anymore, who does Dorothy. Made her way down Fifth Avenue stopping. At a grocery store on 59th, Street to buy some chocolates, then in brentano's, a bookstore on 27th, Street where, she bought a copy of engaged, girl sketches, a lightly, humorous, collection, of short romantic, stories, quite. A lovely evening for, the lit for the for the ladies a nice little jaunt through the Big Apple yeah I. Love, a humorous, romantic, story well this story does not get humorous nor does it get romantic, okay, around. That time reportedly. 2:00 p.m. she, ran into a friend from college Gladys, King the, two talked about a party, they'd both been invited to the same party for, which Dorothy, was supposedly dress, shopping, Gladys, left to meet her mother for lunch and Dorothy. Was, never seen again whoa. There. It comes so the last person this year was Gladys they were talking about the big party they'd been invited oh it's gonna be a corker kind of like Gossip Girl II I guess there's a little gossip well like in the 1910s. Yeah yeah, they, should do a reboot. Oh in that in that era yeah let's, talk about more shows people should watch that aren't the one word I'm so what word establishing. Here is that we got our finger on the pulse of hot searing. Teen dramas, I don't, like how you said that and this. One's gonna be pretty good team, should never be prefaced by hot and searing you're just gonna have you going hi Siri teens, and, then just cut right. There well. That sounds good I'd like to watch oh now they have footage amazing, yeah now you should have both the unsolved, hosts talking. About hot Syrians, I guess at this point we might as well say it in unison ah, searing. Jeans when. Dorothy wasn't home for dinner that night her, family started, to worry the, morning they began calling Dorothy's, friends, by that evening with, no one knowing Dorothy's, whereabouts, the family began contacting private. Investigators. The investigators, searched hospitals, morgues and even prisons looking for Dorothy they, visited her friends in Boston, Washington, DC and other cities, but turned up nothing, detectives. In Europe even watched as people disembarked. From ships arriving, from the US to try to spot Dorothy, nothing. Shortly. Before Christmas with, the private dicks having made little progress the family went to the police when, they two came, up empty-handed the family finally made Dorothy's disappearance, public, On January 25th. A full, six, weeks after their daughter was last seen hoping, more clues would surface, despite. A $1,000. Reward by, Dorothy's family, more than 26, thousand dollars today no. Leads managed, to turn up Dorothy, Arnold that's, a long time I know they had the private eyes working on it but six, weeks, feels like a casual, pace what, are you gonna do I mean it she was 25 years old she could have run away maybe, when a 25, year old goes missing you're not thinking she must have run away you're. Thinking yeah she's probably doing, stuff she's, 25. Years old what do you mean most stuff I mean. When we started this show I was 25, yeah, if, I went missing for like a week do you think you'd be alarmed or what you might think so, that's that's nice I didn't think you'd be alarmed I think you you're my friend I don't like how you said that you said it was you're my friend why are you yelling at me you're right Oh God, I would be concerned if you disappeared, and we'd get a pretty baller season, out of it cuz it'd just be me bein like. With. Almost no clues it's time to make like Nancy, Drew and Nancy, draw up some theories about what may have happened to, the popular, socialite, because. It captured America's, attention for so long this case has countless theories associated.

With It we couldn't possibly go into all of them so today we're, just presenting, what I feel are the most likely our, first theory is that Dorothy, Arnold, ran away after. Searching her bedroom investigators found, information Dorothy, had collected about various, ocean liners she could take near, it, wasn't clear when Dorothy researched, the ships but, the cruise companies, were nevertheless contacted. They all told investigators. No Dorothy Arnold had been aboard their ships in my 20s, it would have been very suspect if I disappeared, because I was for a brief while, very, interested, in McMurdo. The Antarctic, research. Base that's where you wanted to go in your mid-20s you wanted to go to Antarctica, it's. Really cool look and it's there's a lot of ice you wanted to go to a frozen, tundra for, vacation, not just vacation, but I don't I wanted, to learn things and and just live, there maybe, I still can your weird guy man yeah you, wouldn't do it you're weird, dude no I wouldn't do that when, I think oh well you're just like Cabo, baby no, I'm not thinking Cabo, baby. On. February. 6th, 1911. Mr., Arnold received, a postcard, that had been sent from New York City that stated quote I am safe and quote, and appeared, to be signed by Dorothy, mr., Arnold however insisted, it was a fake and that whoever wrote it merely copied, Dorothy's handwriting, samples, that were published, in the papers, I'd, love for this theory to be true I would agree, Dorothy if you're watching this you're probably, 127. Years lady, o lady, but um you. Know good on you you live the good life. Dorothy. If you're watching this comment, top, well vote well get, to the top comment, wouldn't that be this show's greatest, accomplishment, that we pissed off vanished. So much that they unveil. --vs. After they you know that, you got so angry yes he came out well good evening Cooper. Was like, assholes. Listen, I saw what you said about me getting speared by a pine tree Hebe Cooper breaks silence. DB. Cooper break silence to dunk on ghoul boys while. Writing the New York subway in 1917. John Galvin, a man claiming to be a detective, at Scotland Yard grabbed, a woman, and reportedly, declared, quote I know you. Dorothy, Arnold I've got, you at last, end quote, the woman not Dorothy Arnold, but rather a mrs. Smith begged, strangers, around her to help, but Galvan insisted. He was a detective he marched her into an NYPD, precinct. Where officers, let mrs. Smith go and sent Kelvin to Bellevue Hospital for, observation I know you, Dorothy, Arnold come, with me I have. Got you at last. Another. Case crapped, fergal, but imagine, being on, the subway maybe you have your air pods in and some grown man grabs, you by the shoulders looks, you in your eyes and shakes you and goes I got you probably happens a lot in New York I've, got Sabah bleah true you know the subway and such but it's a wild place not, only did he grab her it's not like this was a moment of Terror just a moment he marched her marched her to the police, station made, her get off the subway walked, with her I'm assuming, while holding her shoulder still that's, insane imagine, the people at the precinct, - they this man shows up he's like it's the missing lady, we've got her at last, ma'am. Do you have any ID she, takes it out I, don't get this guy somewhere. Quickly. I've. Cracked it here she is Dorothy give me the money now, over. The following decades. Many others would come forward claiming to have seen Dorothy, or even, to be Dorothy, none, of the claims ever led anywhere, casting. Doubt on the theory that Dorothy, ran away is the fact that she left behind practically. All of her valuables, expensive. Jewelry that could have been sold to help her journey as well as personally, valuable, correspondence. With friends, so, let's say I look like Kim Kardashian and, because, we do yeah and she, goes missing mm-hmm, and I and she's. Not turning up and I. Just really, pore, through the archives, get, a good idea of what she's like, yeah you watched 10 seasons, of Keeping Up with the Kardashians I'll, take copious notes I'll, watch it on a loop for 10 years I show up a little aged yeah. But. Still you know I still. Got it you know it still got what she's got because I sort of look like her and I just show up and I, spent.

A Long time I, feel I took, I fell down a hole I, have a beard I got stuck in a cave and. You just make up a story how. Would like what are they gonna know how, could they possibly tell. Well. They're gonna be like where's that mole on your butt cheek I mean. Don't know that no. I mean I guess, you're right so, guess what suddenly, I'm rolling, in there baby and there's, gonna be ten more seasons that Keeping, Up with the Kardashians. Under. The ran away theory, we should talk about a sub three of sorts that Dorothy, eloped, when police were brought on the case their first theory was that Dorothy, had eloped by the time the New York Times broke the story however that theory quote had been completely, abandoned, and quote, after, investigators, interviewed everyone they were sure knew Dorothy in any way every, one of Dorothy's family members and every, friend they could get the name of no, one was aware of any, secret marriage, but, before investigators gave, up on the elopement theory, one, potential, suitor merited, extra, attention. George, Griscom, jr. George, Griscom, jr. was a Pennsylvanian. Man in his 40s, at the time of Dorothy's, disappearance. The two had known one another for approximately. Four years though, Dorothy's, family never approved, of George mrs., Arnold even went on record to say she would never let George marry her daughter after. She went missing it came out that Dorothy, had met up with George, in Boston, a couple months before she disappeared, she had told her family she was visiting a college friend but there was evidence that Dorothy checked out of her hotel at the same time that George had checked out of a different Boston, hotel reports. Say that Dorothy, may have also pawned some of her jewelry to fund their rendezvous, while, the Arnold's denied this a Boston, pawnshop, was given the name Dorothy, Arnold by someone while she was in Boston at the time Dorothy went missing however George, had been vacationing with his family, out of the country for about a month, even, after replying to a telegram, from the Arnold's, that he didn't know where she was the, family remains suspicious, On January, 16th. Before the public even knew about Dorothy's, disappearance. Dorothy's, older, brother John confronted. George in Florence, Italy during.

This Interaction reports. Suggested, John even hit George and knocked him to the ground in, February. George ended his trip early and sailed back to America, he then hired his own private, investigators. To look for Dorothy, in the, month that George paid for them his investigators. Didn't find Dorothy, even so, if I'm George you are George yes, I'm not George but if I'm George okay you're a creep George I'm creep, I'm, a creep, yeah I want, to marry this. Heiress. Mm-hmm, I paid, for her to go, stay. Somewhere, for a little bit but if we want to open when's the perfect time to do it to, make myself not, look suspicious when I'm on vacation for. A month with, my family so she goes holes, up somewhere, for a little bit yeah, family comes knocking about doors she's missing where she'd been I don't know I'm on vacation, then, I hire. A private, eye you forgot the part where they gave him a knuckle sandwich whatever, if they hit me big deal I'm getting married I'm stoked hire, a private eye he, runs, around town looking for I don't tip him off maybe I tell him like hey by the way this is all bullshit I don't, know oh here's. Extra, money don't tell him well I don't know how much honor gumshoes, had at that time but probably none okay, uh then. I meet up with her later in like Sioux Falls or something, we. Get married, it's. Possible, it's, it's a fart gonna be they like find your identity then easy it seems like a lot of, steps. As opposed. To just saying to the parents yeah, we're gonna get married. Well. I guess. So you're right about that, yes. Yep. Our. Second, theory is that Dorothy, was kidnapped, and murdered this. Is the theory that Dorothy's, father eventually, came to accept as what happened to his daughter in the absence of clues the family came to believe this was the only logical, explanation, by.

April, The family was so convinced, their daughter was dead that they started requesting the police give up the case in fact, both her parents evidently, wrote Dorothy, out of their wills because, they were so certain she would not resurface, look. I am. NOT going. To pass judgment on a family, that is going through grieving. But. Let me pass some judgment. It's. Weird that you would ever want the case to be stopped being investigated I guess that kind of prolongs, the grieving, period but, at the same time if there's a chance you would think you'd want to keep going and then, I don't know how quickly people write, dead, children, out of wills yeah I don't know either, what, is that like six months later about four and a half months that's pretty quick I've, got stuff in my fridge it's, been there that's, a full season it was a full season a. Season. That's, that's, pretty quick it's. Weird that he would jump to that cuz if people were like I'm so sorry I bet, she's out there somewhere and he was probably just like I bet they stabbed her I. Bet. They killed her I bet she's dead I better ride her out of my will it's, a weird thought but once again I don't, know what it's like to go through that grieving process so possibly, this is what their process was and then you know it's weird to us because we're Outsiders and we're idiots and you know we're looking at this 100 years later but I think, we could say that's a bit odd and move on seems odd let's move on perhaps the strongest lead in the murder Theory comes from one edward glenn norris in 1916. Glenn norris was serving time in the Rhode Island State Prison for attempted extortion of, a clergyman, he claimed he found God and wanted, to come clean to the warden about his supposin involvement, in burying, the body of a woman he had come to believe was, Dorothy, Arnold Glenora, said that in what he remembered, being December of 1910. A man at a bar named Benoit asked, for help from him and another man that some reports named little, these. Guys sound suspicious, little. Sounds. Suspicious. Or like the star of many many silent films yeah I mean the only little I trust is Stewart, and that's it but. His is a little Stewart no oh a little oh the mouse mouse. Boy no man here's a mouse man he drove a car little. Louie does say he sounds like a funny little like what's, little Louie up to this week, Oh. Murdering. A woman Benoit. Glenn Norris and little Louie were tasked with moving an unconscious. Woman from a house in New Rochelle to, a home up the Hudson near West Point, the, next day Glenn Norris was informed, that the woman had died and he was asked to return to the West Point home to help bury her, Glenn Norris allegedly buried the woman under a concrete floor in the basement and was paid 250 dollars, for his involvement by a wealthy looking man there has been some speculation that, man who paid Glenn Norris could have been George Griscom, though there's no hard evidence to support this bad, dudes. If your, friend comes up to you and says I need a favor, help, me move a lady and. You're you're like yeah sure into her apartment no, oh no no she, is unconscious. I've, got a mover, just. Oh we could taken her to the doctor no no -, a quiet, quite, home somewhere, upstate where she could rest yeah, yeah. Next. Day by the way oops. After Glenn Norris confessed, to helping bury the woman thought to be Dorothy a team, of detectives searched, a home match England Norrises vague description, on April 21st. 1916. When, they got to the basement the, team was surprised to find an area of the concrete floor that appeared to have been broken up in the past the, area however was, small about, five feet by six inches and the, caretaker, claimed the floor had been broken to fix a gas pipe when, authorities returned, a couple days later with the owner's permission to dig up the spot they indeed found a gas pipe within, the year authorities, were satisfied, that Glenn Horace's claims were false the, third and final theory, were discussing, today is that Dorothy accidentally. Died during an abortion in April, 1914. The Pittsburgh home of one doctor Cece Meredith, was raided by police. Meredith, his nurse and another doctor one each a--let's, were all arrested the home was used as a private office, where woman would come seeking abortions.

Let's Made a statement to the DA that at one time Meredith. Had told him Dorothy Arnold had been one of his patients from, the way Meredith spoke of her let's infer that she had died and her body had been cremated in, Mayor this office, and while Lutz didn't admit to seeing Dorothy himself, he did testify that he'd witnessed another young woman who died in Meredith's care be cremated, in the basement in their, raid detectives, did find two oversized, furnaces, in Meredith's basement, their speculation, that Griscom, could have been who had impregnated, Dorothy but evidence of this or of Dorothy ever being in Pittsburgh for an abortion is scant at best just, two quick things about that one, even back then women didn't have control over their bodies so much that they would have to go to a basement to get an abortion from a creepy doctor who would throw them into a funny little furnace not that that's relevant to today at all donate, to Planned Parenthood but number two. I don't, really, know if, this. Applies to her I don't know if she got. The abortion went there or even got impregnated, by Griscom, or if the Griscom thing is even true so so this may be more. More. Just a wild public, imagination there is circumstantial, evidence, that maybe, this happened because Lutz, one of the three people that was arrested in the raid did, say that the other doctor, had told him that, you know Dorothy. Was one of his patients whether or not that's true who knows she, could have been there before. Disappearing, as well that or maybe he's trying to shave some time off of his sentence just lying yeah, just lying he's, lying yeah. He's lying to get time off possibly. Or it, happened I guess we won't know I mean, sorry. Why we're here yeah I know it's the end of the episode and you were hoping like the. Boys are gonna crack it we never do that's.

The Guarantee stories. Of missing socialites, have always captured, the public's interest, something, about a seemingly perfect life gone astray continues. To fascinate our, darkest imaginations. For Dorothy Arnold a lack of clues that confounded, investigators. Has also given rise to a slew of theories, to debate over for more than 100, years despite, decades of attention, in global searches as for what actually happened, to the 25, year old New York heiress, on that December day remains. Unsolved. What. Theory do you got here if, any now. Me I'm. A bit of a romantic. So. I'd, like to believe that she eloped I think, she ran away just ran away no eloping, just scram, I think she might have ran away and in 1910, how hard is it to run away probably not that hard yeah what'd you burn your ID that's it you're, a new person now anyways check out Nancy Drew on the CW, it comes out on October. 9th Wednesdays this fall she could have solved this case I think I think she could have she's certainly better at her job than we are.

2019-09-28 10:34

Show Video


I want to see the Winchester bros do an episode with y’all xD

The part on women's rights and Shane whispering "donate to planned parenthood" made me smile. Love you guys

I think the aliens of area 51 took her

The lack of cursing concerns me.

All hail the watcher

It would make sense that she didn't want her mother to accompany her on her shopping if she was going to secretly get an abortion. Maybe she was hoping to quietly get rid of the baby, but she died and the doctors got rid of the body #postmortem

LOL how about when i find the f***ing gown I call you

I started watching this at 666k views just to change it because of the bad luck


Can you guys cover the case of Kurt cobains “suicide“ sometime?

#postmortem is no one gonna mention the last person who saw her, Gladys??!! I mean Gladys is a pretty shady name. I think gladys did it.

666k views, 13 hours ago **deep gulp** alright then

If the abortion theory was true, it could explain the family’s behaviour. Say, the family found out about the circumstances of her death... they’d probably want to bury that information since pregnancy out of wedlock and abortion were considered very shameful. Those reasons, in that time, were enough for a family to disinherit their daughters. If they truly believed she was murdered, they’d at least want justice right? But if they somehow knew she died because of abortion, they wouldn’t want anyone to know, even the police. #postmortem


Please make more of these!!!


Am I the only one who thinks that moving to Antarctica sounds like a dream come true?

Shane sounded like Jerry Seinfeld when he exclaimed

Shane: YOU’RE MY FRIEND Ryan: why are you yelling at me you’re my friend Shane: YOU’RE MY FRIEND Ryan: ohh my god Shane: I WOULD BE CONCERNED IF YOU DISAPPEARED and we’d get a pretty baller season out of it cause it’d just be me being like I don’t know what do you got anybody seen em

I'd watch an episode of just Shane trying to fill up the time while constantly deviating from whatever little material he'd gathered

STREAM chicken noodle soup by JHOPE ft. BECKY G :). (I’m sorry

Why do so many of these cases include some one with the name Francis

"The Kardashanes"


Sooo are we going to get another video today though

bfu really feeding us huh

This season is already hilarious

So, on their Supernatural ghost hunt episode. I'm expecting them to go to a Haunted Lighthouse.

"Let's talk about the shows we get paid to talk about"

#roastmortem the fact that Shane can look like a hippie, drug addict and a lesbian aunt really scares me

#PostMortem George Is involved basically in all your theories! 1. Does he have a wedding certificate? Maybe they did elope? 2. She was going to a party and maybe he got mad and got her killed. 3. He took advantage of her and thats why she wanted the abortion.

Y'all dont even mention the ND computer games smh

Shane yelling "you're my friend" at Ryan is so pure

When’s the real bun coming back?

Just saying what if her parents did something to her ....

As she kept like buying dresses or something and they got annoyed with her spending money ??

Here I am, boys

1:40 Mommy said not to go downtown

Let us assume she decided to run away . That's possible She had 750$ Possible #postmortem #boogara+shaniac

“little stuart?”

Omg finally another episode

Can you do a video into the death of princess diana ??

Guys... the greatest show in existence just existed *Keeping up with the Kardashanes*

What if the parents knew she was pregnant, sent her to the creepy doctors themselves, that's why they were sure she had died...

The perfume importer's middle name is Rose. Seems legit.

I'm laughing too much for a tragic disappearance case.

I'd binge watch all seasons of 'Keeping up with the Kardashanes'.

A perfect case for you guys would be the "Orderud murders" in Norway. 4 people sentenced to prison but it's still allot in this case that is a unknown today, and the convicted still claim today they are innocent. After they have served their time in prison they even hired a private detective and tried to get the case reopened.

12:57 wait wait wait... what happened to “febeeyary”?

For the #postmortem What if the parents are ones who kidnapped and “vanished” their own daughter AND that’s why they wrote her out of their wills. The parents could have wanted to get rid of her because they was tired of her overly privileged attitude of hers?

Let's Nancy Draw up some theories

ryan and shane are inseparable... Ryan what would you do if Shane's gone missing ? #postmortem

This looks like a case for C.C Tinsley

What if she was abducted and then her kidnappers left the cruise books or whatever behind to make it look like she ran away?

I wouldnt trust Stuart Little he a rat

Yo where the qna video for ann a bell

hey you guys could do about the disappearance of the erebus & the terror naval ships, loved the amc series but i'm not sure that an evil polar bear did it

for Shane's theory about pretending to be Kim if she disappeared: the police will probably have your fingerprints checked and see if it matches Kim's (unless they don't have Kim's fingerprints)

Shane and Ryan mention Gossip girl; this show just got a whole lot better.

0:07 Shanes blank stare XD

For postmortem : Just a theory i got while i was supposed to study for my exam . Her brother John could have kidnapped or murdered because he wanted to be the sole beneficiary of their family's will . Maybe the parents knew maybe they didn't. Like you guys mentioned the parents removed Dorothy from their wills 4 and 1/2 months after she went missing and i agree with you , that's too soon to remove your missing daughter from your will. That's definitely not gonna be on my mind if my daughter went missing. And they only notified the police 6 weeks after she went missing and they even told them to stop the investigation. Tell me that's not suspicious

Ma bois are back baby!!!!!!

Keeping up with the Kardashanes

#postmortem what if she got pregnant and the family found out and was so disgusted they got rid of her. Explains why the had the case close and why her father was on the kidnapped and murder ish

America in 1916 : looking for a missing woman Ireland in 1916 : in a war for independence

You know what would be an amazing content and also very helpful? You could add a new category about children or any person missing . You could either dip into old cases to prevent kids from being unsafe out there or help the people who are currently missing in the world. You guys have the platform you could help so many people, think about that. We love your mystery videos but I really think this would be interesting and can make a change for the better

4:33 Does that man look like Cillian Murphy as Tom Shelby or is it just me?

Ryan and Shane were then escorted by the FBI, and were never seen again

If they could make Nancy Drew, why not the Hardy Boys

is there a theory, where the parents/the dad have something to do with her disappearance/death?#postmortem

#postmortem could you possibly give a brief run down of some of the other theories, like in one sentence? love u guys!

Imagine like 40 years later she calls her mum saying “hey yeah, found my dress come take a look”

Maybe she went to Brum to live with the peaky blinders

Nobody: Literally no one: Ryan: CABO BABY- OOO OOO OOO

"HoT seAriNG TeEnS!!!!" -Shane Madej and Ryan Bergara 2k19

Start your own podcast please

Can u guys pick more interesting case. This is episode so boring , just my honest feedback .

Yay you guys are back

I think they found her married, and instead of dealing with the shame of who she married they swept it under the rug and wrote her out of their will.

I really want to see Shane and Ryan go to Antartica! Make it happen BuzzFeed!

My 70 year old grandma doesn’t watch YouTube and u think a 170 year old woman is watching YouTube?!?!?! Edit: the 170 year old woman is Dorothy

I think she married George when they met and her surname changed that's why when they called the cruise companies there wasn't any Dorothty Arnold because she was Dorothy Griscom now.

Wait they bleep the swears now-

Donate to planned parenthood! ❤️✊♀️♂️


Doesn't sound that impossible...

That should be turned into a series...

We love being up to date so I can follow the new episodes

19:40 excellent points made by Ryan

Edward Glenorris was taking about a rich looking man paying him. it have Dorothy's brother...

Am I the only one getting the vibes that the family could’ve paid someone to off Dorothy?

#postmortem if you look at the time period and the fact that she belonged to a wealthy and well-known family, it might have been easier for the family to accept that their daughter is kidnapped and murdered than the fact that she eloped

I'm with Shane's take on theory 1.5

Admittedly there doesn't seem like much, if any evidence against the family, but I can't help but feel like they had some form of involvement.

I really think it was her brother, to try and get her out of the will? #DorothyArnoldPostMortem


*"So let's just say I look like Kim Kardasian-"*

*She got abducted by aliens*

U have been gone for soo long

If I were a person like Dorothy and decided to ran away, I wouldn't take all of my jewelry to sell it, bc they could trace me from there

I feel like there was so much to this family that we didn't know.... rich people hide things like this. There was probably a lot of backstory here that no one except the relatives are aware of. Was John trying to get his sister to disappear so he could have the family fortune? Did her parents do some sketchy business that she wanted to expose so they got rid of her? The world will never know... #postmortem

#postmortum If Dorothy was looking for European holidays and George was holidaying in Europe she could’ve gone to Europe and used her’s or George’s money to pay the cruise company to tell the police that she wasn’t aboard any ship- or she could’ve cruised with a fake name. So they could’ve married abroad in Europe and vanished or when George came home Dorothy could’ve stayed there or went with George and hid somewhere then moved out into a house with him. (She could’ve changed her name or took George’s to stay hidden- she even might’ve been Mrs Smith from the subway as ‘Smith’ is one of the most common names people use to hide their identity) :)

for #postmortem ... is a little bit weird to me that dorothy´s parents took 6 weeks to take her disappearence to the police even with their private detectives looking for her AND removed her from their wills after 6 months... i MEAN, what if they found out that she really run away and took her of their wills to block her acess to their money?? and never told that they find out because it would be "easier" to drown out the scandal that this would be. it would also explain why they asked the police to close the case. they could also had something to do with her disappearence..

if y’all really wanna hear a story like the kim kardashian one, look up “the return of martin guerre” is the same thing in real life


As you can see at 7:56 the mannequin in the window thing was still there but at 8:09 it wasn't but at 10:18 it's already there And the disappearance and reappearance of the mannequin remains Unsolved

What if its theory 1.5 and 2? What if her family killed her because she was going to disgrace them by marrying someone below her station?

17:22 the other wealthy man could have been john which is the other heir of the money. maybe another theory? like the guy out of jail could have been brought for questioning on who might have paid him?

The dad did it

I kind of like the idea of Shane and Ryan disappearing on one of their ghost hunts, only for the Worth It guys to take over next season by hiring three different detective agencies at drastically different price points to find them.

5:43 Inside shane: "if he escaped from the king of hell I would be hella shook"

Hell yeah, y'all are back. Binged watched the past episodes and now waiting for new episodes with you 2 has sucked lol.

For Postmortem, I think it's a mix of all the theories. The parents organised for her to 'go missing' as a result of her wanting to elope with her boyfriend, who also may have gotten her pregnant. Her parents didn't want her to be an unwed mother, and also didn't want her to marry that guy & realised the fortune was in danger so had her killed off and written off the will.

none of the theories were family foul-play related? like her brother could have done it so he was guarenteed all of the family fortune? or the parents could have done it or arranged it because they found out she was pregnant out of wed-lock to a man they disapproved of? the whole point that they gave up after only 4 months and everything doesn't sit right with me.

"I'd like someone to give me a lot of money for doing nothing" Hmm, you don't have to go anywhere, Shane

LESBIAN THEORY! Dorothy did elope but with a woman. The family no longer wanted it investigated when they found out and wrote her out of the will in case she came back to claim it after their deaths.

Theory: Maybe someone was blackmailing the family to close the case and write Dorthy out of the will. #postmortem

Shanes perfume would smell like fruity garlic

... donate to planned parenthood... LOVE THESE BOYS

Do all Americans pronounce Dorothy like this? Or just these guys? "Door-thee"

Ryan and Shane are basically the Lucifer and Chloe of Buzzfeed, I'm just saying. An impulsive guy who runs around looking for trouble and the partner who babysits him half the time

"so now we get 10 more seasons of the Garb-Kardashians" LMFAO

No one: Literally no one: Not even the aliens in Area 51: Shane & Ryan: *hOt sEariNG tEEns*

Shane is being too friendly now I believe he has realized people are finding out he’s a demon and he has to hide it better

"keeping up with kardaSHANES"

Bruh ryan be looking like kakyoin in his pyjamas


nobody: shane: YOY'RE MY F R I E N D

What if she changed her name and then went to the ships which is quite clever from her

What if her dad found out about the pregnancy and killed her before she could cause a scandal? #postmortem

In his 20s my dad spent 6 months in Antarctica as a physicist, studying the Aurora Borealis. I don’t blame Shane for wanting to spend time in Antarctica; it sounds pretty dope

So proud of Ryan for learning how to pronounce “February”

I bet that Dorothy did elope, her family found out about it but felt too ashamed so they decided to write her out of the will and have the police atop looking to avoid the news getting wind of it

If kim Kardashian ever goes missing,i think we know who kidnapped her

#roastmortem Keeping up with the Kardashanes sounds like ones of those ‘based on’ porn videos

if it weren’t for Ryan & Shane, I wouldn’t know that there’s gonna be a reboot for Nancy Drew lol #postmortem

I think the parents changed the will in case she eloped. They wanted to make sure that her husband had no claim to the family fortune.

youre my friend!!! *wh- WHY ARE U YELLING AT ME YOURE MY* YOURE MY F R I E N D !! !!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!

Who else chuckled when Ryan said "Private Dic"? Hopefully I'm not the only one.

Ryan: * continually insults Shane * Shane: *YOU’RE MY FRIEND*

Do madiline mcann

*Y O U R E M Y F R I E N D !*

The thought process of the grieving parents was probably along the lines of, "If she ran away, that means she doesn't love us, doesn't care about our grief..." but if she was murdered, it takes the blame off of Dorothy for not making contact or coming home. It's really sad, but I kinda get it

I think she was kidnapped and held for ransom and the parents didn't go to the police as one of the conditions. They killed her when the kidnappers weren't satisfied and possibly the prisoner was involved. Maybe her and her possible boyfriend even staged the kidnapping to begin with but it could've gone wrong.

i'd watch 10 seasons of keeping up with the kardashanes

Why is the name Glenorris sound so familiar? Like there's been someone else in these season's with that name.

I love you guys and everything that you do! I wish sports unsolved would come back.

All I can imagine is them saying "Hot! Searing! Teens!" and then someone editing the clip of them touching their nipples to follow that. What is *up* this season, bros? You guys okay? XD

i heard it as " hot tirin teens "


Shane is literally me to all my friends: “YOU’RE MY FRIEND!”

My theory is that she is somewhere over the rainbow #postmortem

Shane: "You're my friend!" ☺️☺️☺️


*ssssssssss mmmmmnmm... [chipmunk noise]*

0:05 Shane looks enthralled

Who thinks they should do Rebecca Zahau’s case next caz that’s like still unsolved if im not wrong?

I might be crazy but I think they switched from a real studio to a green screen type of thing and it’s weirding me out

#PostMortem - Did anybody bother to check to see if there was a Dorothy (or Dot) Griscom at all? ;)

Good lord Ryan. “...and nAnCy dRaW uP...!”


Shane couldn't pass as Kim K they would DNA test his booty so fast #postmortem

#postmortem I got all my family into buzzfeed unsolved even my nan, we are all Shaniacs sorry Ryan .

Is noone going to point out their fashionable clothes this episode

I kind of wish the abortion theory was explored a bit more. The parents writing an heiress out of their will and cancellation of the investigation matches with views on abortion at the time. It's sad to say it, but in some families, kidnapped and murdered is a lot easier to handle than failed abortion and death. Leaving home with a lot of cash too? I wonder if there were any deaths confirmed to have been caused by the same place #postmortum

#postmortem I have a strong feeling that it must have been her family, no one writes their children out of will so quickly. that to me just sounds very suspicious, or it could have even been her brother that just wanted her share as well

Do the mysterious death of Tutankhamun

“Donate to planned parenthood”

"In 1910, the 25-year-old left her home..." "Dorothy, if you're watching this, you're probably 127 years old..." What... what year does Ryan think it is...???

14:24 when Shane says "Well..." I thought he'd end it with "Love gives strength at the cost of the mind"

750$ to buy chocolate she was wealthy

Shane is Dwight schrute. That's my conclusion.

So y'all are trying to tell me that Ryan is half of the channel that BuzzFeed, a large corporation, had to make because of his wild success.... And they don't pay him enough for him to have $750 in his account right now. And they probably don't pay Shane any different. We just love that don't we.

-are ghosts real?- *Which chipmunk is getting the best head?*

I think his brother has something to do with her sudden disappearance so he can get all their family fortune

What if the brother killed her? He bribe someone to kill his sister or kidnapped her. And then he comfronts George so that he won't be suspectected, faking that he mourns for his sister's death? What if he was the Little Louie and he suspected that Glenorris might spill out the beans so he moved his sister's body to a new abandoned basement or to a cemetery? But one of the investigator or detective crack it and tell it to Francis. Francis tells the police to stop the searching because she was killed but never told them that it was son who killed her daughter because he wouldn't have a successor for his business. #postmortem

so far we have ryan rubbing his nipples, calling shane daddy, and yelling "hot searing teens!" three times. okay. edit: also ryan getting (obviously) genuinely upset over women's issues and shane telling people to donate to planned parenthood has cleared my skin and raised my grades

Yehey!!!! They are back


I think she might have been kidnapped by Aliens

Parents (both equally involved) killed her. Whether it was direct or via an abortionist's room doesn't matter. She shoulda stood up to them years before and left.

I believe her family had something to do with the disappearance. As stated in the episode; I find it very strange/odd behaviour to: 1. Wait 6 weeks after their daughter went missing before reporting her disappearance to the police. 2. Encourage police to stop investigating, after only a few months, and then promptly remove her from their will. Seen many parents hold onto hope that their disappearing child is still alive somewhere, and never give up searching for them until their death. Either her family was cold-hearted as hell, or they were involved in some way. #postmortem

“Private dicts”

Seriously love y'all even more now

#postmortem so when is the premiere of keeping up with the kardshanes??

Shane is definitely stoned in this episode! Shout out to Shane tho, if I worked for buzzfeed I’d have to be constantly smoking weed

Private..... Dicks? I just-


Leave it to buzzfeed to sneak endorsements to murdering babies into the show about murder. Ironic and sad.

Disappointed to hear you support the assassination of babies, even when the woman is an adult and has the resources to take care of him/her. But ok, I still enjoy a good mystery.

"I want someone to give me a lot of money for doing nothing - millennial (2019)

How did she expect to get from NY to Pittsburgh and back in one day? In 1910.

16:34 Lil J Hap Hap Ta Pap ...This, for sure, sounds like gibberish for anyone who doesn't get it.

what's your favorite animal? #postmortem

“I don’t even have $750 in my bank account” honestly same

Thats broke broke

her brother was responsible for her disappearance! he got rid of he so he didn’t have to share the inheritance

what if it was her parents. two wealthy people in 1910 could surely very easily disappear their daughter.

When Shane said “ WHO DOES!?” at 2:44 I thought it was a Jerry Seinfeld clip #postmortem

Couldn't they just follow her scent?

god dangit

Sadly, theory number 2 is probably closer to the truth of what happened to Dorothy Arnold. Whether she was kidnapped for ransom, leverage or simply because she was an eye-catching female some turd decided to have, it sounds a lot like most disappeared women's fates.

I still see that fcking maneqquin behind that winfow over there

cant wait to watch the edgy nanny drew movie!

My theory is that Dorthy, unfortunately was murdered and her body was never found. My reason for this is she seemed to have a happy comfortable life so there would be no reason for her to run away, also if she had run away why would she leave her belongings and valuable items. It also doesn’t make sense for her to just suddenly up and leave when her goal that day was to buy a gown for an event she had planned to go to. It just doesn’t make sense to me why she would run away. #postmortem

Wait they still do this vid?

4:47 Am I the only one who misheard the word after 'private...' xD

Madeline McCann Unsolved?

You guys should do a True Crime Unsolved Mystery on Marilyn Monroe's death.

Nobody cares about you....just get on with the mystery

5:50 I'm so sofT

True crime is soooo much better than supernatural

I somehow always end up watching these at 3 in the morning...

I felt uncomfortable watching lol

0:40 "I like someone who gives me a lot of money for doing nothing" Can relate

I didn’t like the Nancy Drew promotion. I hate when channels interrupt to flog something they’ve been paid to.

Great episode, though I really could have done without the 'Planned Parenthood yay!' thing. Personally I think Dorothy might have eloped.

have you guys notice the mannequin has an eyes and mouth

dorothy never left the house because here mother killed her because of the argument and her mother dressed up as her and talk about the party

"I don't even have $750 in my bank account" I feel you

#postmortem say if she did run away and changed her identity, then it’s not too far stretched to imagine that some of us could actually be related to her and don’t even know it

i miss watching you guys

I'd go to Antarctica for a fun time

Shane looks like he's trying to give up cocaine

"old lady! ooooooold lady!" tf was that even XD XD XD

hi my name is dorothy


galvin : “I CRACKED IT! I FOUND DOROTHY ARNOLD!” me : “yea you’re definitely... associated with crack”

Please investigate kate yup

She probably ran away with the guy her parents didn’t like and they found out later and then didn’t want the media to publicize the bad marriage so they claimed she’s murdered and cut her out of the will so she’d never have their money

“Shortly before christmas, with the private dicks having made no progress.” Ryan 2019

4:52 haha, dicks

"yOU'RE MY FRIEND," "why are you yelling?" *"yOU'RE MY FRIEND."* "I-" *_"YOU'RE MY FRIEND."_*

Announce 1 hour Madeline McCann special pls


I think the reason they wanted the case to be closed and accepted that their daughter had died because this case blew up and as you mentioned a lot of people were trying to benefit from it. The family may have gotten tired of all the drama and false claims.

Disappearance of ma370 /flight 370 plsT-T

DNA tests, Shane, DNA tests...

10:58 how they gonna know DNA testing: am I a joke to you

Ryan is me laughing at my own jokes..

Imagine us all trying to find Ryan lol

No one think that maybe her brother or father is the one who kill her or cause her to went missing? I mean who will think begging the police to stop finding their own daughter? I think that maybe her brother set all this up and perhaps force his parents to beg the police to stop investigating so he could get all the money?

I am safe. - D. Arnold


I wonder if Dorothy got pregnant and was sent to a home for unwed mothers, like the Magdalene Laundries, and then was kept there to work like a lot of the other girls after she gave birth. Or if maybe she ran away to be with someone, and then her parents found out where she was later but thought it would be better to have her remain "missing" to protect their social status/honor. Either one of those could explain why her family so abruptly and thoroughly stopped looking for her. #Postmortem

Shane DNA tests my friend the Kardashians would want a DNA test sorry to tell you you can’t fake DNA


at 10:52...wouldnt they know if she had a mole on her buttcheek?

Abortion theory makes sense. She had a lot of money on her, and didn't want her mother to come with her. Could be the case.

Keeping up with the Karda-shanes

Anyone notice in these videos which awesome that ryan says he instead of she alot

#Postmortem maybe she eloped with a girl??? would explain how none of her friends seemed to know about her whereabouts, as a social elite she might have been terrified of judgement from both her family and her friends and just disappeared off to europe with a hot babe

Private dicks?

maybe she didn’t find the dress she wanted in manhattan

next company to make a dark and edgy update of anything is getting guillotined

Ryan only has $700 in his bank account I hope to god that was a joke these guys have millions upon millions of views and fans please Ryan tell me that was a joke please

As someone who carries cash more then my card I feel offended

I think parents discovered she had an abortion and then spread she got murdered to save face! Might explain why they were so 'sure'.

Look i'm feeling a little offended that ryan thought it was weird Shane wanted to go to antarctica in his mid 20's. I'm 23 and one of my biggest dreams is to go to antarctica so that when I come back I can do huge landscape paintings of it. Things like this are why I'm way more of a shaniac than a boogara. I came out to have a good time, and I'm honestly feeling so attacked right now.

You guys should do the unsolved murders for Georgette Bauedrof

Maybe she just decided to finally live out her lifelong dream of being a pirate


No-one: Shane: "So let's say I look like Kim Kardashian..."

Me trying to convince people I like them: “YOURE MY FRIEND!”

Some people think that she killed herself. She did want to be a writer, and try to get her story's published, but they kept getting rejected and her "Suter" said that he didn't want to marry her. There more videos that going into the theory.

"Where is that mole on your buttcheek". I'm literally dying.

Keeping up with the KardaSHANES!!!

Honestly I think it was her parents who killed her or something because she was spending alot of there money on shopping and partying. Considering the way her parents moved on after 4 months I mean..


In all seriousness,Shane if you had a perfume or fragrance ,what will it be #postmortem

4:50 am I the only one Who hears him say private dicks because I'm kind of confused hahahaha

Jury: Your looking at about 36 years Tekashi 69: So you know dorthy ran right?

guys so our best bet is to convince shane to leave buzzfeed ryan is for sure too brainwashed to be swayed. if that fails we will just have to viciously bully ryan into submission not ideal but it would work

LOL, Ryan looks like he just woke up. But I am so surprised why they couldn't show the real photo of Dorothy Arnold? I did a quick Google search and I was able to get it. Why couldn't they use it here?

This story reminds me of the Matt Damon movie "The Talented Mr Ripley". How's the creeping, Tom?

You mean a night gown?

What if her parents were the ones to kill her. They may have seen Dorothy as unfit of being an heiress because of her spending and attitude and they might have gotten rid of her.

I wish I had that much quiche

If she wasnt murdered that very same day she disappeared she could have run off with someone and started a new life. My grandmothers sister disappeared in 1905 and no one ever knew about her. My grandmother and her older daughter took it to their grave. About 15 yrs ago my parents were notified by the relatives of the new family she had started in Washington. We all lived on Long Island and were very surprised. She took off with a friend of her father's.

Maybe her parents truly did move on. They wrote her out of their will to prevent people who had the same idea as Shane looking like her and appearing 10 years later from taking advantage of their money.

For #postmortem: Given his track record, I'm surprised that Ryan didn't suggest that Ms. Arnold was abducted by aliens. #shaniacs

Still waiting for the video about the dancing french people

She went to Europe, tried to come back in 1912, died in the sinking of the Titanic. Boom, I'll take my award now. Edit: This is mostly a joke for anyone who might get salty

but is no one suspecting the brother? idk??

I think the person who killed her wrote that letter either that person felt sorry or so that her parents would stop the investigation. What i find weird is her parents taking her name off the will. Why did they do that? It could only mean they knew she will never come back. So if they knew she will never come back and they know why ,it could only mean they are hiding something either to save a family member or some secret of hers/the family's. This way the outside world won't know their/her secret.

Keeping Up with the KardaSHANEs

I’m still kicking....

Maybe she ran away with her lover George. And the parents knew about it that’s why they removed her from the will in exchange of what she have done.

Ryan: Yeah I mean... The only "little" I trust is Stuart and that's it but- Shane: Little Stuart?


my great grandmas name is Dorothy Arnold...

10:10 Did Shane forget about DNA tests?

What if she got on the titanic ? Remember it hadn't set sail until 1912.

Its hard to count how many times they went off topic in this episode

Expecting the ghoul boys to ever solve a case on a series called buzzfeed unsolved is an impossible expectation

5:47 Me showing affection to my friends

I would watch every season of Keeping Up with the Karda-shanes!!!!!1

Is it just me or is this show not the same anymore

They're talking about perfume right as I put on one that smells like vanilla milkshake, cherry on top, pink lemonade, fresh cut grass clippings, and waffle cone. Wild.

I have the same last name as the abortion doctor

Please make an episode of the unsolved murder case of the Chiong sisters! Hehe

It does seem a little sketchy but maybe they wrote her out of the will do discourage people from showing up years later claiming to be her in order to inherit her fortune. #troublesoftherichandfamous #postmortem

i love shane

Yes! You guys are back!

She's in Antarctica #postmortem

they carry the $850 million Buzzfeed company on their shoulders, but they’ve never had more than $750 in their bank account

*keeping up with the kardashanes* I lost it

1:18 (chipmunk noises)

Maybe she found ruby shoes.


Why in the hell are we sensoring Ryan and Shane? Gtfoh

Theory: Dorothy ran away from home because she didn’t want to eat that sad excuse for pasta.

miss ya

#postmortem Ryan i am disappointed that one of the theories wasn't that she was kidnapped by aliens

Wouldn't Dorothy Arnold getting into contact with the boys make this a Supernatural episode?

This show is a comedic romantic honestly #shyan

Last theory is believable

sounds like alien abduction to me

Guys do the murder of Amy mihaljevic. It's is almost the 30th anniversary

I was thinking maybe the family knew that Dorothy and the guy eloped after sending out the investigators for six weeks, and since they are a rich and well known family, it sounds like the thing she did would bring disgrace for them. So "removing" her name from the will is sort of a removing her from the family, and them saying she died or rejecting her letter or spreading rumors she got kidnapped were just cover ups. Plus this to Shane's theory, it could be like a cheesy drama plot but it could happen. it just sounds wrong for a family to give up easily and for George ordering to kill her. #postmortem

What if it's her own brother? Her brother might have killed her for the will and assets.

(Chipmunk noise)

Why is no one talking about how good Ryan looks with the shirt and sun kissed skin??

The Kardashanes!

*H O T S E A R I N G T E E N S*

she joined the sewer people

The abortion theory is interesting, but considering she was a wealthy, connected young woman, she no doubt would've had access to a more reputable doctor who could've performed the procedure safely.

y'all are not serious enough for me... so I unsub from yall Channel,

What if someone held her in captive in the basement. And she died in the captivity

next minute kim kardashian gose missing shane ses here i come world

well. helloo. im dorothy and im a fan of BTS. Make this as top comment ☺

Shane looks like Benson from Regular Show

Watching this at night LOL... ...I’m scared, please help

shane you NEED to explore antarctica before your too old they are HIDEING LAND the earth is wayyyyy bigger than they say forget those flat earth weirdos just believe me the earth is wayyy bigger and the UFO are coming from our earth in areas beyond antarctica think shane space is too far for any craft to fly but people are seeing ufo so they are coming from somewhere when you take away the impossible what your left with is the truth in the end the ufo came from our own earth we were just lied to thats all .

just a big fat commercial xP lame!

Do a video about the missing Australian prime minister Harold Holt

ok listen ryan has honestly gotten funnier since they started this show

Really unsettled me cause my last name is Arnold and that her brother’s name is John Arnold, which is also my father’s name. Kinda intriguiged if I’m related to this set of Arnolds. #postmortem

Bad pun Ryan, no, unacceptable, do you not know your limits

Just a guess: maybe on the day she went out to buy her 'evening' dress, she actually had an abortion scheduled as she was carrying George's child (which physically-speaking, a 4 months pregnant tummy could still be relatively passable as just putting on a chubby belly, and therefore her buying a new evening dress reasonable). Her chocolate purchasing may have been a pregnancy craving, and her bookstore purchase of 'engaged girl sketches' may have been her day-dreaming about a possible matrimony with George and having a family. Then maybe her parents DID find out about her dying during the abortion (probably through a quiet confession that they managed to keep away from the media and police), and them writing her out of their will makes sense to distance themselves away from the guilt, shame, and grieving of losing their child and potential grandchild. Considering how pre-marital sex and abortions were viewed and handled with socially during that time period, I don't think that would've been far too off that her family would be ashamed to reveal the truth if that was the case. Also, whaddup ghoul bois come down to Asia one day

Cha Cha real smooth

her brother killed her he could’ve killed her to inherit all their parents’ money. and the flying over to punch her alleged bf could’ve his way to look like a loving and concerned brother? maybe he even told his parents later out of guilt and they decided to write her out of the will and ask the police to stop looking for her cuz they had their closure

PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE DO AN EPISODE ON THE MISSING BEAUMONT CHILDREN FROM ADELAIDE IN AUSTRALIA. It is such a strange case and I’d love to see you do an episode on it :)

"Grandma, it's me...DOROTHY!"


Donate to planned parenthood? Really?

#Postmortem - SO folks here we go with another ridiculous theory that I like the sound of. What if Dorothy did elope, just not with George. What if Dorothy eloped with another woman? It would explain absolutely no one knowing about a secret lover, considering the publics view / treatment of LGBT people at the time. And what with Dorothy's family being quite high up and wealthy it would have been a huge scandal. This could also explain the parents stopping the search and writing her out of the will so quickly... if they had found out they would have wanted it covered up as quickly as possible. Not to mention the fact that if evidence suggesting this had be found it would have quickly been overlooked or dismissed. History is pretty well known for denying the existence of gay people (the classic tale of "oh here's this famous historical woman who lived alone in a house with her best friend for 30 years..... )

Have they done one that covers the death of Edgar Allan Poe? I’m pretty sure the cause is still under many speculations.

shane: you’re my friend! * everyone liked that *

I beleive she went to the party... and some thing went wrong and the rich friends cleaned it up fast.

Tbh it seems like her parents had something to do with it. When they "gave up" on the investigation, that's when they could have heard from the doctor that she died during the abortion? I can't imagine them being okay with her getting pregnant out of wedlock with a man that they disapprove of.

You guys should do an episode on the disappearance of Eddie Aikau! Everyone in Hawaii knows the story and it's remained unsolved for decades


7:18 i felt the amount of effort he put into saying february in my soul

0:39 WAHHHH only why dont we fans can get it❤

Guyyyssss omggg you should do the killer clown craze

If she was kidnapped I feel like they would have sent a ransom note. Her parents have a ton of money so why not try?

will you guys please pretty please do an episode on qanon i KNOW you can make it funny

"Private dicks" -Ryan

The boys: that would be our greatest accomplishment Vanished: well now I’m not going to


#PostMortem What if the family killed her? They were so eager to say that she died and to write her out of the will, plus dorthy seemed snippy to her mom, maybe they were tired of it and decided to keep the money too themselves since she mooched off it. The fact that she wanted to marry a man that she couldn't have, she lived at home still, and didnt seem to be leaving any time soon could have been a factor. Didnt they want women to be married soon? She was getting a little crusty and they decided to cut her the money sandwich. Shane will you ever make a series like hotdaga again? Also ryan make one too please, or if you could what would it be about?

what if the family knew she went and married george and that’s why they removed her from the will so that he wouldn’t get any money

Shane, my daughter is in her mid-twenties and she is living in Antarctica!

"Dark edgey new Nancy Drew's teens" Said on this date by Ryan and Shane. Everyone heard it!

Y’all should do a video on the “dyotlov pass incident”

Postmortem She went to get the boat to Europe to meetup with George and elope. Something happened before she got to him and that's why George got a private investigator because he didn't know what happened to her either

The abortion theory makes the most sense to me because if her parents or the public were to find out about the abortion she would be shunned. I think her parents found out about her dying during the abortion and took her out of the will because they were disappointed and they knew she wasn't coming back.

Shane has such Michael Scott energy this episode

i lost it at Karda-shanes

“I want to get a lot of money, then I want to vanish from the face of the earth.” Damn I felt that

I’m Dorothy Arnold, I have hid for most of my life but have come out of hiding for this. I don’t care for your impression of me Shane!

Night gown: *exists* Ryan: “sleepy time gown” Night gown: “am I a joke to you?”

My theory: Dorothy was the inspiration for corpse bride

I'm very about the abortion theory. The timeline of visiting Griscom matches up with the timing of an abortion. She was a part of a wealthy family who (obviously) didnt seem to care about her (4 months?) So she decided that instead of coming clean about a pregnancy with a forbidden love, she decided to take care of the issue herself. She grabbed a book to read while waiting and the abortion went wrong. She was cremated and that's that.

my theory...she did need an abortion and was taken to a friends house to rest when she started bleeding so they had to call those two guys to move her to a quieter place closer to a doctor who could be bought and she died from that and is still buried under the house with the pipes

pretty pretty please do the unsolved case of Blair Adams next? I promise if you even just take a peeksie at the facts behind the story you will be so intrigued you won't be able to NOT do an episode about it ;)

10:35 I can’t get enough of Shane

I totally thought Shane said he wanted to BE an heiress, not date

Please do an episode on Brian Shaffer, truly baffling stuff.

What if she just tripped and like died

19:42 we stan shane’s feminism

Hot Spacey teen's

I’ve never watched an unsolved mysteries and laughed soo much

Okay yeah, the Parents killed her


12:58 wait wait wait wait WAIT. Why is no one talking about how Ryan pronounced “February” correctly?

When he said $30 like it was a lot I was confused, then he said *$750* . *WHO IS CASUALLY CARRYING $750 BUCKS???*

19:42 thank you shane

Shane at 19:41 = the *best* effing boi ever

Mom- Sleep Me at 3am- Oh buzzfeed unsolved uploaded new video, night made!

Shane's perfume *Shanell num 5*

“Donate to planned parenthood hood* *happily continues watching.* I love you two.

we need an episode where shane does the research and explains a case to ryan

15:33 "I'm sorry I bet she's out there somewhere-" "THEY STABBED HER :D"

But, did they consider Upside Down to look for the missing girl? #postmortem

Can you do an episode on the disappearance of Madeleine Mccann pleeeaaassee

That f*cking mannequin to the left gets me every time

Buzzfeed is for mongoloids

If you showed up as Kim they'd do a DNA TEST. THATS WHAT THEYD DO y'all really out here letting each other run w anything

What if she ran away and contacted her parents later? Her parents were so angry that they cut her off and not willing to find her anymore. #postmortem

19:34 but I thought she had control because she (in the theory) asked for an abortion. Maybe she was ashamed because she was pregnant outside of marriage so she didn't want to go to a big hospital, risking to meet people she knows (and maybe made her parents know about her secret love life). I mean, a lot of people, even until now, seek for abortion from "experts" because they didn't want anyone to know that they were pregnant due to similar reasons.

No one: The porn ads on 123movies: HOT SEERING TEENS


Maybe they wrote her out of the will to discourage scammers from pretending to be her or have found her?

I’m 28 and planning a trip to Antarctica hahahaha

So Dorothy did you find a dress?

were fake ids a thing then? how did the police know that the “fake Dorothy” wasn’t her?

When they talked about Kim Kardashian look-a-likes I was reminded of the storyline of Anastasia.

[chipmunk noise] 21:51

*watching a show called Unsolved* mmmmmmm I wonder if they are going to crack the case and tell me who did it.

my theory is that her parents had something to do with her disappearance due to their suspicious behavior after she went missing. I mean, that short amount of time and you try to bury the case and write her out of the will?? maybe they were tired of having to fund her lifestyle. and its interesting to me that they contacted private investigators before they contacted the police after 6 weeks. I know people handle grief differently but its odd how they handled things. i also think they may have spread a few rumors about George, trying to throw people off the scent and give the public someone else to blame. which would also tie in with the fact that George felt the need to hire his own private investigators to find Dorothy. it would make sense that if they got rid of their spoiled daughter, wouldn't it be killing two birds with one stone to pin it on the man who your daughter saw behind your back when you forbade her to do so? #postmortem

#postmortem my theory is that the family was involved in her disappearance. It's mighty suspicious how quickly they removed her from the will and urged the police to stop the investigation. It isn't uncommon for people to cover up crimes by showing concern and jumping into the investigation. Obviously money wasn't a concern to them if they put up a $1,000 reward AND paid for all of those private investigators throughout the world. I think it's possible that Dororthy was involved with her friend or she caused some other kind of scandal that could have destroyed the family's reputation and they couldn't let the word get out. You didn't mention them investigating any asylums, which seems strange to me, so maybe they had her committed somewhere (which was not an uncommon way of dealing with women who had their own opinions and didn't conform). Of course this is all speculation, but I do not get any good vibes from that family.

What if the parents, or one of them, killed her?

donate to planned parenthood!!! I love you guys even more now

I commented like you said. Stop saying my goddamn name and I'll reveal myself to the public! Sincerely -Dorothy

#postmortem The abortion theory makes a lot of pieces fit! If she met up with George Griscom Jr. a couple of months before her disappearance, around the time of her disappearance she would have known that she was pregnant. Being a pregnant, unmarried socialite in 1910 would have brought ruin to her and her entire family. Due to the conservative views of the 1910s and the family's disapproval of George, she most likely never even told the family about her pregnancy and went for the abortion in secret, hence telling the mother to not meet with her until she found a dress. She would have given a fake name at the abortion clinic, not that the clinic would have notified the family of her death had she given a real name. My guess is that the PIs the family hired found out about the abortion and the family kept this quiet due to the ruin it would bring. This would explain their certainty of her death only 4 months later and writing her out of the will. It's also very likely that George never knew that she was pregnant and had no idea what was happening. HAS NOBODY SEEN DOWNTON ABBEY?!

This case eerily reminds me of the disappearance of Barbara Newhall Follett due to the similarities. Both were 25 years old when they disappeared, both only had $30 in their wallets, both American - one from New York and the other from Massachusetts, and both were not reported as missing immediately - 6 weeks for Dorothy and 2 weeks for Barbara. Might just be a coincidence but the similarities are pretty creepy. #postmortem

sometimes i feel like shane isn’t breathing

Did Shane's mom have a one night stand with Dietrich from Barney Miller? (only old people will get this..)

"no one heard of a secret marriage" ...... isn't that kind of the point of a secret marriage?

I had to rewind the video 3 times to make sure Shane said Sioux Falls

i feel like maybe dorthy and that one guy did get married and ran away together and when her parents found out they were so ashamed that they just wanted to stop the investigation and write her out of the will and stuff so quick. idk man shits wack. (btw i love you guys.)

She was obviously killed by the elite because of something she did. This sort of 'strange disappearance and deaths' of influential people isn't uncommon. Everyone is trying to chase the throne of power and control.

D.B Cooper is my favourite mystery, alongside the legend of King Arthur.

"Even back then women didn't have control over their bodies..." "Donate to Planned Parenthood." if any of you DO want to donate to planned parenthood (like shane says) you can do it here:

Ryan going missing on Buzfeed unsolved would be like that one time when all the animals had to save the wonder pets

Yes? Why are you looking for me?

4:20 ok but that pasta looks so good though

Is this the testimony of how low and desensitized today's society has become? Am I the only one who do no feel the urge to laugh at these two poking fun at a mysterious disappearance, albeit a very old one? It is in very poor taste and it's quite disturbing seeing these guys behave this way.

not relevant to the actual case: CW's Nancy Drew is a trash joke just from the trailer (Nancy kissing a MURDER SUSPECT? Seriously?) PLEASE tell me this wasn't sponsored by them...

I would like to live in Antarctica

Ryan, the word you're looking for is nightgown 2:15

They're officially back. I don't count the area 51 video cause I need crime.

no one: shane: “cAbo BaYbEEy

Honestly with the way she talked to her mother, I think she was ready to run away

I would loveeee to see the ghoul boys cover the mysterious disappearance of Barbara Newhall Follett, the child prodigy/author

4:17 he looks like John Lennon

Yeah, she sounds like a brat

I honestly believe her family murder her and had others take care of the body. It’s very well that the wealthy lookin man that paid him to take care of the body was the father. They showed no signs of remorse and quickly wrote her off of their will. I don’t know seems fishy

I'm Dorothy. I'm right behind you Btw.

Votye c spring

Did Shane do the whole Kim Kardashian bit for that one pun? Did he leave out the possibility of DNA testing that way he could finish the bit for the pun? I guess it’ll remain..... Punsolved.

I live near the bellview hospital, its SUUUUPPER creepy and abandonded its now a park you can visit everywhere around the grounds of the hospital is abandoned. Some of my friends have gone there to investigate and heard noises and things inside I really want to go but theres a lot of aspestus. the weirdest thing is that theres now a soccer field right under the building ( the pic used in this episode) that little kids play soccer games lol.

In 1910 there was a major boxing championships, I highly doubt Dorothy was there though.

Are we going to talk about the Nancy drew pun or not

Nvm just remembered the cover for the season is the Hardy boys and we love an aesthetic

Maybe she got lost in the upside down

No one: Shane:

Ma ghost boiiiis, I have seen these 2 in ages

(2:17) Ryan, do you mean a.... nightgown?

“maybe even a sleepy-time gown” so a nightgown??

The parents gave up!! That's insane! Yeah it could the time and their status, I just know if something like this happened to one of my siblings or myself, my parents would never give up or stop looking. You don't. You just don't. Shame on them.

Its really scary and crazy that people really just disappear out of nowhere like this...

Something has to be said that this girl was 25 years old, still living with her parents and never married? During this time that is very odd. The median age (according to google) a woman got married during this time was 21. So I’d say she was the black sheep of the family and there is way more to the story than we know. This is why the family cut her out of the will so fast. It may have been that they figured she’d find a way to manipulate the system and get her inheritance out and the family didn’t want that if she was going to be with George. As far as whether she eloped or died. My thoughts are she got pregnant when she met George in Boston and she either got murdered or died in an abortion. George sounds like he was no good. 40 year old with tons of money and unmarried?! Something fishy there.

Oh , and D B Cooper was Dorothy Arnold

Id go missing if that was my supper too...

Y'all should start doing more Jane and John does

y'all are going to jail!1!!!1! PERIOD!!!!1111!!1

do Munir from Indonesia

January 25th you say? T h a t s m y b I r t h d a y

"It's time to make like Nancy drew and Nancy draw up some theories" hahahahahahahahha I'm sorry what!!

6:50 Your call Shane

Girl loves boy. Girls family hates boy. Girl lies to family abt where she is to go and eff her boyfriend in a hotel. This story seems familiar...

"the private dicks".....

Where is the episode on the Orderud murders! Like, it's such an interesting case

her parents did it #postmortem

*"He's a Mouse Man. He drove a car!"* Ryan was serious about that!

I’m gonna try to be cool with your food babe babe love yeah yeah sure

Can we talk about how Shane got extremely defensive when Ryan asked if he went missing would Shane notice and then just keeps yelling “YOURE MY FRIEND”


“New York is a crazy place” As a New Yorker, I can confirm that

why is it every time Shane does something or a voice you have to then do the same thing with your spin?  not funny. and stop with the quote unquote thing.  its even more annoying.  we can see its quote.

Do the zodiac killer you’ve been missing out

In the captions at one stage it said “hot Syrian teens” and I was so confused

4:20 That pasta looked like cookies n cream ice cream for a sec (not wearing my glasses)

I have got u at last

At 10:39 *Shane and Ryan: Ahhh, it's me Kim, I fell down a hole~~ I have a beard now~ I got stuck in a cave~~* good lord x"D

Omg i could not get past 2 mins of this video. The side commentary interruptions are so annoying i could not take it. Please just tell the story and stop jumping in with your unfunny interruptions!!

The evidence on Dorothy Arnold eloped and her father finding out she went with George Griscom jr. maybe the reason she was written out of his will is quite strong. Albeit it was a complicated plan by George by having her "stashed" away somewhere while he is on vacation, it is not too much out of the realm reality to do it and execute it as it just needs for Dorothy to go out on a certain day while George is out, have suspicion cast away from him, marry Dorothy and return months later already married and probably with child. But having her removed from the will may have been the reason for them to never return to her family and just move on somewhere else... or maybe because she is no longer an heiress... maybe something more sinister happened to her after.

damn did shane shout out sioux falls sd???

censoring swear words ? I actually liked that ryan and shane could say whatever they wanted without being beeped out :(


Ryan: So you want to be a trust fund baby? Alexa: Now playing Trust Fund Baby by Why Don't We.

If Ryan dissapeared this show would just become Shane being a real estate agent for haunted places

Hey guys it's Dorothy Arnold just letting y'all know I'm safe and living my best life in Cabo baby

Can you guys look into the Timothy Pitzen case??

Please bring back ruining history

7:18 hahahahahhahahahahahahahahha feb

Maybe it's a small town thing, but cash is definitely carried here by most people. Actually the place I work only takes cash, we don't even have a card slider on our registers. But my town also has 3 beer drive-thrus and no movie theater so...yeah. cool story, bro. ~FCA

Glad to see the creepy mannequin behind Shane is gone

"So if I'm George" *"You are George, yes"* "I'm not George, but if I am George" *"Okay you're a creep, George"*

For postmodern: Why were the parents not suspects because their actions seemed suspicious, like who would claim that the letter wasn't real when their daughter was missing and why would you want the investigation to stop? Love you guys

I’m Dorothy Arnold

#postmortem Pfft, knew there was gonna be a pregnancy theory. No wonder they wanted her gone considering the shame involved. I mean, my guess is the parents were told what happened and tried to shutdown the police investigation because they knew they would’ve been shunned from their social circles, which as sad as it is was probably easier to deal with than finding out she had been murdered. By cutting her out of the will, had she been found was them disowning her and proving to their circles that their family didn’t find the behaviour tolerable. I hope she eloped, but with a 40-year-old... eh?

"and i'd love for you to disappear" *mood*

Do the 2001 anthrax attacks!!

Shane sounds like Jerry Seinfeld sometimes and it absolutely kills me

She probably went to a parallel universe. That has happened to people.

What if Dorothy was going to meet with someone else at the party? Probably she was getting to know someone else and George didn't like that so he kidnapped her and kill her? #Postmortem

No one: Shane and Ryan: Cmon lets say it together, *HOT SEARING TEENS*

hang on. an unmarried 25 year old woman in 1910? girls were married off quite young and popping out babies by then. this is a capital L Lesbian who ran away from home to avoid being married off to a man, word made it back to her homophobic parents, who subsequently asked the police to drop the case to save them the embarrassment/public shame of their daughter turning up alive, well, and gay, and they took her out of the will so that once they died, their lesbian daughter could not ever resurface after they've died and claim inheritance.

Did my dude Ryan just call the private investigators Private Dicks

in unison: HOT SEARING TEENS!!! lmao

3:11 ok...

I think the abortion one makes the most sense bc if they burned her body there would be no evidence and that’s why there were no clues

Nancy is a teen detective? Sounds like a 90yr old

Hey wait a sec my name is dorothy... Wait where am i?

Hey, do a true crime episode on Bob Crane

salem witch trials !!!

Oh.. What a wonderful, peaceful day *You feel a hand on your shoulder* Shane: "WE'VE GOT YOU AT LAST"

Do the disappearances of the British colonist in Roanoake Island!

he started the show at 25? wtf he looks 20 i-

Do another true crime

Love this case!

Honestly it sounds like she was getting an abortion, died, and her family found out and was ashamed so they didn't make it known and went along with the investigation for a few months. OR because they took so long to go public, they may have somehow inadvertently caused her death (like not getting to her quickly enough) and the guilt made them call it off and write her out!

What if Mrs. Smith was actually Dorothy, and she got a different identity. What if she wasn't a doppelganger, but the really one?

greatest quote::::::::::::::::: "next day, by the way----oops"

Am I the only one who agrees with Shane at 6:41, that going to McMurdo in Antarctica would be an awesome experience?

why are they trying to get me scared about dorothy eloping


Get this to the top comment because I’m Dorothy Arnold.

Little stuart

When you have absolutely loved Shane for all these years until this episode when he says "Donate to planned parenthood". Shane stfu

The fact that the family took her out of the will so fast makes me think they know what happened to her, also the fact they asked the police to drop it. Like, either she eloped and got pregnant and all, and they learned about it and were like "ok but now you're cut off" (which is not a stretch - it was 1910 and women had no control over their lives, specially rich women, to decide who they wanted to marry), OR she could've died during an abortion, yes, and her parents just didn't want anyone to know about it cause it would be a hell of a scandal so they just pretended she disappeared and that was that.

Why was the brother mentioned only once and never again? If she was the heiress doesn't that mean the brother got the money? What would her spouse even get out of killing her? A wealthy man paid those dudes? Sounds suspicious to me. Everyone always suspects the maybe-boyfriend, but the brother could've easily done it, not wanting to get his hands dirty and paying off those guys. He even caused a scene with George (Who knows? Maybe George suspected her brother himself and got clocked in the face for it). Not to mention her parents writing her out of the will a mere 4 and a half months after she disappeared could directly relate to the fact that her brother convinced them to? Her father seemed plenty distressed over her disappearance, and spent so much money in order to find her (including the reward + all of the private investigators they went through), so it seems kind of redundant to go through THAT much effort if the murderers were her parents. I'm genuinely baffled as to why nobody's investigating the brother, or not even so much as suspecting him? Siblings have definitely killed each other for less. Logically speaking, it seems the brother had the most to gain out of her death. Not to mention he could've been jealous if she was the family's beloved daughter, when it's usually the man in the family who gets the perks--at least, back in that day. Worth looking into, maybe! #postmortem

The abortion theory seems very plausible, circumstantially. Good home life, didnt take any valuables, told her mother she would call her later, bought chocolates and a romance book before disappearing... definently sounds like she intended on returning. And the whole waiting 6 weeks to make the disappearance public and everything with George... idk seems like the family would want to keep something like this under wraps. The $750 she left with also couldve been to fund the procedure and pay off anyone.

OK but I used to work for a 107 year old named Dorothy..... coincidence?

The abortion theory explains why she didn’t want her mum to go shopping with her:

The Boys are back

we stan some progressive ghoul boys

I like horror movies, but there ads. You could just be watching a video and then you'll just hear screaming from a horror movie ad

Kim Kardashian

If you pay any attention to anything BuzzFeed puts out that doesn’t involve Ryan and or Shane we can’t be friends.

I'd go with the abortion theory and that the family found out about it and that's why they wrote her out their will.


I trust lil pump

Ryan doesn't even have $750 in his bank account? You got to be worth more to Buzzfeed than that.

"nancy draw up" oKaY y'all, simmer down

I choked when he said "I dont even have 750 in my bank account"

Her family killed her

I would definitely watch gossip girl in 1910s era

Shane giving me 'I LOVE YOU DOG' vibes when he says Ryan's his friend

is it just me or does shane's shirt match the color of his lips a bit?

"Hot, searing teens!"

merideth is secretly msr. lovett from sweeney todd

You should look at Ted Kennedy’s chappaquiddick incident. I know he didn’t get caught for it but whats unsolved is whether or not he made an attempt to save her

Ryan : *softly* " I have a beard now.." Me: JESUS CHRIST DUDE!!!!!

my payee is doing just that getting free money each money and it doesn't disappoint, downside the bills happen to arrive daily, each stacks of bills that comes in each day are at least 6 pages thick each no joke I get the mail but when I don't my mail never gets to me don't worry already on it too


Yo these to, ahahaha

Shane wants to go to McMurdo? Great, now he's The Thing.

"finger on the pulse of hot searing teens," more like the pulse of cold lifeless teens because anyone who was a teen when gossip girl aired is 25+ now ... ouch #roastmortem #postmortem

I feel like the abortion is the most logical and least sad one

Maybe shouting *YOU'RE MY FRIEND* will drive Ricky Goldsworth away

I'm surprised no one suspects the brother - I mean having the inheritance all alone could be a good motive to make your sibling... disappear. #postmortem

You guys should do a video on Tara Calico.

is it just me or are Ryan's eyes puffy in this ep?

*_tb cooper breaks silence to dump on ghoul boys_*

I thought Ryan would be pro life, since he's too afraid of ghosts. :(

for the post-mortem: can you investigate why the cw and other channels insist on hiring grown adults to play teenage characters

The fact that Shane didn't laugh when Ryan said private dicks blows my mind

Pretty please give us a #postmortem for this one.

You work for Buzzfeed and you don’t have $750?

The abortion makes a lot of sense, it would also explain the punch a lot more and the weird grieving from the family if they knew about it.

0:51 in and Shane's voice sounded so offended at Ryan's "And I'd love for you to disappear"

I would watch keeping up with the kardashanes lmaoo

19:41 Shane championing for women's rights can I get a hooyah

When high, I can’t understand Shane. Is this bad?

Imagine Shane (who is now Kim Kardashian) and Kanye in the same room !!! #postmortem

Megan Nichols FAIRFIELD ILLINOIS murdered at 15 by? remains found wrapped in blanket in field not far from fairfield. by farmer years later. it’s a small town people think it was her bf which was a state cops son so they weren’t caught. we’re told her remains are currently with the fbi and she still hasn’t has a proper funeral.

"I'm getting married, I'm stoked"

No one: Dorothy: aight Imma head out

“Yeah we’re going to get married” 2019

Maybe she did get pregnant by griscom( the hotel meetup) and her parents told her to get an abortion(why thr doctors knew her as a patient) but ended up not going through with it and her parents wanted her to vanish as a result to avoid the shame so she quietly disappeared and had her baby and they wrote her out of the will so she could not come back after their death for her inheritance. The six weeks was long enough to disappear

I’m just curious as to how you know of Sioux Falls cause no one effin ever references us.

Two things that should never change about BuzzFeed Unsolved: 1. Ryan is the one who does the narration. 2. The duo of Ryan and Shane.

D. Arnold got pregnant by george. Parents wouldnt ley them marry. Sent her off to have an abortion, which she died during and was tossed into a furnance, but her parents knew, but had to save face, so weeks after being missing they hired detectives and then and couple months later claim she was kidnapped and murdered and then written out of their will. They would rather have had that, than her marry George or have a bastard grand baby... therefore making all 3 theories accuratish

excuse me young man, i am greatly offended by this. take the video down immediately.


I was hoping for someone to make an account in her name and comment on the video, I’m disappointed.

Do Dennis martin

I think that maybe the guy that said he helped bury her might've been telling some truth. What if she was kidnapped, they were gonna hold her for ransom but whatever injury they had caused her to knock her out; like a hit to the head, actually killed her which is why they originally were just going to move the body to a "house upstate" but they ended up having to bury her, maybe the cops just went to the wrong house or maybe he gave a bad description of the house #postmortem

1:24 Oh Mr Dalliard. Have your boys taken up a sleuthing job on the other side of the pond?

Shouldn't there be a postmortem for this?

y’all should totally do something on Anna Anderson and the whole people pretending to be Anastasia Romanoff debacle!

It’s so funny how most top comments are just repeating what Ryan and Shane are saying.

those boots are so cute i can’t get over them

I think she ran away and was really seen by all those people

lmao i was born january 25th

Here's a link to the public domain book listed at 2.56

Most people want to go to europe while shane over here wants to go to Antarctica

Why'd it take you so long to get to my case?

thank you guys for giving a little shout out for women's rights. i honestly don't even care about the crazy right wing antiabortion comments here and you guys shouldn't either

wait was that pasta on the plate?

Ok so this might be far fetched but what if like she got pregnant like someone said but instead of her family killing her she ran off and killed herself


Shane’s fragrance line should be “Made Madej” or “Made by Madej”

kind of off topic but im sick of entertainment companies making "dark and edgy" reboots of my favorite shows. like HOW was sabrina the teenage witch in any way dark and cultish. i cant wait to see how they're gonna pull off buffy the vampire slayer in that light. also good show i love you shane #postmortem

5:47 when your friend says that they have no friends and you're honestly done with arguing with them at this point so you tell it to them straight

Benoit? Jeanne Benoit????

what if she took a vacation

What about the parents?? If they wrote her out the will because she was spending all the money. They got someone to get rid of her. If they can afford a private detective why not an assassin?

I'm pretty sure the parents did it because they waited so long to make a police report, and waited longer to announce it to the public, and then they told police to give up the search

Can you make buzzfeed solved

how much did an abortion cost back in 1910 she did have money on her? its possible

either she ran away, or her parents killed her. those are the only plausible solutions.

the thing abt planned parenthood the boys said made me go

I love the idea of a teen drama based in the 1920s! I'm going to write that right now.

I call my 3 year old cousin little Louie, sense he was named after my aunts husband... so he’s like the little version of him...

When they were describing her day all I could think about was “she ran away to be with her lesbian lover” and I dont know why

"Unsolved" still remains the only thing worth watching on BuzzFeed. Besides "Worth it" and the "Try Guys"

Do Madeleine McCann!!

5:47 is my favorite part


The fact that there was evidence to support that she had an interest in traveling to Europe wouldn't be unlike. It was acting common practice during those times for rich heiresses to marry for titles. They would often be arranged to mary men with titles and even princes. However the common practice included a large dowry to encourage the establishment of marriage to these men. In similar fashion of Grace of Monaco. When an American receives a foreign title of nobility, the American must relinquish their American citizenship by law.

I love Shane’s “donate to planned parenthood” quick quip. Because please, donate to planned parenthood. Planned Parenthood is very necessary!


ive watched 1,2,3,4,5,6 series finnaly

please talk about the disappearance of madeleine mccann!

She wasn’t happy with her life in the US, took a boat to Europe, took a different name, stayed there for a few years before deciding to come back to New York, boarded the Titanic and died in the sinking.

The family did it. Why wait so long to report? Why write her out of the will? Why INSIST the police stop. I always think the family is guilty tho. Or the abortion theory #postmortem

8:38 Is anyone else getting deja vu? That name sounds familiar.

please dont donate to planned parenthood lol

My kitty is named Little Biscuit. Does she sound suspicious? She does sit on my Playstation when she's been explicitly told not to.

She been kidnapped then sold to dubay as slave

Could’ve been she committed suicide because of (1) maybe there is a pressure being a socialite, knowing that her family didn’t report her disappearance one of the reasons may be of public embarrassment, like her father seems to be so strict and believes what he wants to believe and also (2) her failed writing career. But I would like to believe that she just ran away and the real one that sent the “I am safe.” postcard to her father. #postmortem

Shanes whole kim kardashian thing is basically the plot of one of the adams family movies lmao

Random Sioux Falls reference, thank you.

I’m starting to feel that they really don’t care about this series. They barely make any true crime videos, mainly supernatural ones. I mean I don’t care if people like those ones, I personally don’t but other people still like them. But give some love to the true crime fans.

Do the sumpter county does

What if her body was underneath the pipes in the house? The pipes could have been put in place to keep authorities from being suspicious.

I was waiting for Ricky Goldsworth to come up as soon as Theory 1 was discussed :((((

The parents did it

This is exactly the plot of the Luxe YA book series in which the oldest daughter of a wealthy family fakes her death and moves out west to elope with one of the family “servants” because her family would never approve so....could be what happened here, I don’t think it would be hard in 1910 to make yourself disappear

Eloped with a woman I bet! I think she may have been a lesbian

why is Shane looking at the camera like that at the beginning? I'm scared.

I would like to see shane and ryan doing a escape room

If these two aren't ballin I'm blocking Buzzfeed

Hold up Ben wa???

U guys should do cases from other countries in Asia. There’s a famous unsolved serial muderer from South Korea that has a lot of weird leads

These two are so getting haunted

Shane in the quietest voice: Donate to Planned Parenthood..

A lot of things are plausible, especially since it IS 1910 and $30 is actually $750!

Keeping up with the KardaShanes....... *Kris Jenner can ch0kE

is Shane ok..... 0:11

Love this channel lads! From

Whyyy do they have to remake nancy drew. Please dont ruin nancy drew. It looks just like riverdale /: make original content ffs.

The family had her killed, ima pass judgment lol. Probably because they couldn't control her and didn't want their money going to someone or something they didn't approve of, not unheard of.

this is a kind of weird suggestion, but i think they should talk about like the whole thing with the 20 findings of severed human feet around Washington and British Columbia in the Puget Sound, its really heckin bizarre lol


I think she ran away or was mugged

Just saying, Shane’s fragrance should be called ‘The terrified screams of demons’

WOW i missed the true crime series so much

@Shane 07:16, that's pretty much the sign for drunk in ASL so maybe you were onto something!

I am safe -Dorthy Arnold 2019, 127 years old.

I honestly think her family killed her/had her killed because she was a lot to handle and was more hassle to keep around. I don’t think the brother knew or was told about this (or he was and it was all a show with going to Italy). I think the man who paid the guy who “squealed” was either Dorothy’s brother or her father. At 25, most children weren’t in their parents homes, they were married, and even had kids. They probably saw her as a “failed bride” along with her being still childish and hard to handle.

"these are the theories I feel are most plausible" I already know ones gonna be about aliens

Do one on Connie Converse

This is such a Gossip Girl thing lol

Actually Shane they would know about that mole.

look up tcnj trash chute death. it would be the perfect true crime unsolved video

Yes the Ghoul Boys are back!


You guys should do Madeleine McCann or someone else idk

Can we stop with the No one: Literally no one: Not a soul: Comments? They’re annoying an unoriginal

My theory is the parents didn’t want her to inherit all their money so they paid someone to kidnap her and just blamed it on George or maybe lied about not liking him and actually paid him to do it that’s why they took her off their will so quickly

I personally feel threatened as a teenager, *HOT SEARING TEENS*

15:45 Also, Ryan, Rich People

5:40 I’m timestamping this for whenever I’m feeling down and need to laugh at something

Ryan: "The only Little I trust is Stuart." Shane: "Little Stuart???"

i watch this show to escape politics and be entertained please don't bring them into this show.

Accidently clicked on this video not realizing it was BuzzFeed

This is the poor man’s version of Rhett and Link and I’m okay with it.

My theory is that the family had something to do with it. Four months is not very long at all. #postmortem

Now ya just gotta summon dorathy arnold case solved (jk)

love these guys but correction dont donate to the murderers at planned parenthood

That agressive "YOU'RE MY FRIEND!" Was adorable

Bruh I wanna live in Antarctica!! smh it is not weird

Chipmunk noise though

The sad thing is. I used to work at kfc. And when the whooper burger came out. People would come through the drive through and when id ask what they wanted, they would quite literally just make the "spicy hot" sound with their mouth like. "Can i get a *phff*". Like on the tv ads. So tbh dont be surprised if someone steals that chipmunk sounding perfume and makes millions off it.

Shane sounded like Barry B Benson at 2:44

Y'all dorothy didn't go to Europe she went to Kansas to see if she could go to Oz like the other Dorothy

When he was with his "family" was his wife and kids. Maybe if she got pregnant and said she was going to tell his wife. Maybe he had her killed.


nancy draw books are better. i hate the new ones. the old ones are like the best thing ever.

Why did they have to do the “dark and gritty reboot” on my girl Nancy drew she doesn’t deserve this.

I trust lil Wayne w my life

“keeping up with the kar- kardaSHANES”

this might be one of my new favourite episodes of bfu

She def hopped on the Titanic and dipped

Get A BuzzzzzzzCut S H A N E p l z

Why is Ryan dressed like the boy in the striped pajamas?

please do missing 411 cases!!!

Is a sever has had 3,000 dollars in my wallet before. Low-key gave me so much anxiety, when I realized I had that much the next day I deposited that s**t as soon as the bank opened.

At 2:43 , Shane sounds like Bob the Tomato from Veggie Tales

The adjectives in front of the title are getting hilarious

They need to make a podcast

Honestly the people who work on this series carry the entire Buzzfeed company

The “Kardashanes”

Dorthy and George eloped because she was pregnant. The parents dropped the case because they felt disgraced by Dorthys actions and they decided to collect the life insurance policy. Case closed.

I think she died having an abortion.

We are friends!?

i was waiting for ryan to say it was aliens tho

uhhhhh ᵍᵘʸˢ

The Kim K part killed me.

I feel like the parents know something... sorry if any family member/descendant is reading this but to me this is kinda sus...

Ok but actually I’m glad I’m not alone in wanting to go to Antarctica lol it seems so cool and who else can claim that they went there??

I’ve been found out!

Reading the title "The impossible disappearance of Dorothy (Arnold)", all I could think was: she's in Oz, don't worry, she'll be back as soon as she clicks her heels. Just me?

Theory(ies): She did get pregnant, it was probably by George Griscom. Her parents found out and forced her to have an abortion so as to not be an embarrassment to the family or ruin her chances of marrying in the future. She either died during the process or attempted to resist and died somehow in that process— which would explain why the family was so odd and moved slow on alerting the police. It would also explain why, on the night of her disappearance, her mother told a friend that phoned to look in on her that she had, in fact, returned home and couldn’t speak on the phone because she went to bed with a headache. Maybe she got the abortion, made it home, and died from complications later— to avoid questions the family covered it up and that is why they were so eager to move on after a few weeks. OR. They forced her to get the abortion and instead of doing that she ran away (maybe with the assistance of Griscom or the father of the baby) and her parents knew this — but wanted to save face so they pretended she had went missing and just let her go off and live her unapproved life. This could explain them waiting to tip the police off AND the reason they wrote her out of the will so quickly. If she was still alive, but living outside the realm of family approval— and the parents faked her disappearance— then imagine how embarrassing it would be if they died and suddenly she showed up to collect her inheritance. That would explain the reason they changed the will so quickly. Also, perhaps her brother chased Griscom down because she had disobeyed their wishes and had ran off — maybe they didn’t alert police to give them time to chase her down and convince her to come back and do what her family wished for her to do... but they couldn’t track her down and Griscom didn’t help (which is why he got popped in the kisser) and so they went with Plan B of getting the police involved and acting like they had know idea what had happened to her.

Please please pleeeease cover the death of Kurt Cobain

Ben Was? Like the vaginal eggs? Wow, those were certainly differently times.

Shane : I'd love to get a lot of money and vanish from the face of the Earth Ryan : Id love for you to disappear

I am so glad that I can just open another window and put on some happy music in the background to deal with the fear bubbling up in my poor chest (Please don't judge me! I need my sims music or I will not sleep tonight!!)

11:01 the karda-shanes.

The next socialite disappearance you should do Pulaski's Masterpiece the poodle. This was cool though

Here’s the theory with George. I think it’s likely because back then in the 1940s, parents needed to approve. Society was like that. People really didn’t get married unless parents and family approved. Also the murdered one. That sounds bad because what mom would move on from 4 months???

Buzz feed is holding them back... they could make a lot more money without buzzfeed... I mean like the “ try guys”... But idc I love them Anyways... so never leave lol

Funnily enough, there is a documentary (It's called the imposter its brilliant!) about a guy that faked being a missing child so if Shane wants to be the next Kardashian there are ways of doing it! But they should totally cover the case, see if they know what happened to the real child

The pathetic attempt to put some humor in this disappearence.


I feel like she was killed. Also she had a good family life i am sure she would not accept not seeing her family at all just to marry a guy no matter how much she loved him

Keeping up with the kardaSHANES

Nancy Drew

Back then being involved with the police was scandalous, which is why the family waited. In 1910, any unmarried woman would have been ruined by having a baby; having an abortion was unthinkable. If the family discovered she *might* have, it would not be surprising if they stopped the investigation and wrote her out of their wills. And yes, there were morning dresses to wear at home, afternoon dresses for going out, evening dresses for dinner and going out at night, and even nightdresses (nightgowns). And Shane thinks he knows history!

i find the father very suspicious..

Insensitive, disrespectful and tasteless Yet Exhaustive, organized and hilarious. Great value to these series as they let the rest of us come face to face with the horrors of humanity without somehow losing fate in humility. Y’all got a new sub right here

i loved buzzfeed unsolved before and I love them even more now after the "donate to planned parenthood" part

I believe this is a case of a young woman just taken off and starting a new life of her own.

Those glasses look gay!

4 1/2 months is enough time for a person to be long gone, but not enough to give up on them altogether. People still show up years later.


Oh Ryan how I love when you always passive aggressively threaten Shane’s life

All women who seek abortion deserve to be gone like the way dorothy did theory 3


Did any one else get a Nancy Drew ad halfway through??

is it just me or do they remind you of cody and noel?

Keeping up with the Kardashanes

Y’all should do Marilyn Monroe’s case next!

No way I just got a Nancy Drew trailer right before this ep. Once it started I thought it was part if the ep but noooo. Coincidence?!. I THINK NOT

2:43 shane temporarily turning into Jerry Seinfeld

OK is this the clue of the three black keys??

liberal propaganda, glad i watch them with adblock

You guys just crack me up

Anyone else get a Nancy Drew commercial?

sleepytime gown? shudder....

Shane right at the beginning is my last brain cell thinking about conspiracy theories at 4am

nancy draw up really made me roll my eyes so far into my skull lmao ok dad

I think she and george loved each other. Her dad didn't approve, she became pregnant and she feared her father. George told her to leave all her stuff behind and casually leave. If she would have packed up her stuff or sold her jewelry her father would've been able to locate her. She probably lived in George's family summer home until it was time for the baby, however she became ill, and eventually died.

"It's horrible this woman died" "Donate to planned Parenthood" so they can murdered millions more?

bruh she got impregnated by the man her family didn't want her to be with. When they found out they forced her to get the abortion. When it went wrong they came up with a story to cover it up, sent dude away, and when the police started getting too close they called off the search.

Keeping up with the shaniacs-10 seasons (each season has one episode)

lmao I got a nancy drew ad on this video



Do the West Memphis 3

yo i think the abortion theory kinda makes sense??? like, she met with the guy she wasn't supposed to meet a few months before she disappeared... after the meeting, a few months later, she noticed the signs of the pregnancy and she made an appointment to that secret abortion place. and, on the day of her disappearance (the day of her abortion surgey), she bought chocolate and a book which are great things if you are rehabing in a hospital (or in a basement surgery room, you know) after a surgery!

The brother was quick to violence. That mixed with the four month parent thing I'm suspicious.


Why don’t they do one on madiline McCann

I legit got an ad about Nacy Drew before this video. I thought nothing much about it until I heard Ryan say "Nancy Drew".

true crime > super natural

They don't go to the police for 6 weeks???? Yeah.... Daddy knew something. A ransom maybe?

"Hot searing teens" you guys were obviously talking about the 1910's being an awesome place for a new TV drama, I see no cause for alarm ;)

When Shane said, "Yea. I'd be worried," My soul kinda melted. It was so sweet because we don't really see stuff like that. I felt warm.

sooo i have a strange nickname... people call me stabby sam... not a gangster or a stabby guy... was just a victim of a crime

"you wanted to go to Antarctica in your mid-twenties???" "It's a very *cool* place"

me liking a buzz feed video: wait no what was I thinking

It’s crazy you a real one if you’ve been watching this since 2016

I literally got an ad about Nancy drew like and hour ago

Hi the music scares me shitless

I got a ad for Nancy drew before this....what?

Idk why but their vids haven’t been showing up on my feed at all so I’ve missed so many

"I would love to be an heiress" Same, Shane. Same.

Y’all should do the Burger Chef murders for Unsolved

i think we’re missing the perspective of a wealthy person here (no offense shane and ryan). personally i agree with shane and think she eloped. it might seem like it would’ve been easier for dorothy and george to just tell her family that they were getting married but it probably wasn’t that simple for her. her parents were probably really adamant that she’d marry someone they’d approve of because she’s an heiress so they’d want that money to go to someone they trust. plus, she has to think about if the public would approve because her high status means they’d also be judgmental of her life. if george had enough money to hire private investigators and go on nice vacations i think he’d have enough money to pull the whole thing off without needing any of dorothy’s valuables. anyways, maybe next time bring kim kardashian in to give her socialite opinion.

Did anyone get an ad about Nancy Drew before seeing them they say they're showing Nancy Drew

can you please do madeline mccann?


at 6:09 you can hear shane laughing at ryan

I got a 'Nancy Drew I'm dieing...XD

I like how they spit out episodes

Me, who lives in Sioux Falls, SD: Why the hell would you come elope HERE!? XDXD

Whenever they said Gladys, I thought of Pheobie's doll

Okay excuse me I really want this 1910 gossip girl

i went to hot topic the other day and someone had written buzzfeed unsolved as an anime they wanted to see more of

A good idea for a season would be making ryan disappear some how and make shane follow clues to find him kinda like looking for alaska but shane can interview actual detectives and police in the process and ask for tips

Do one on The disappearance of Andrew gosden

Plot twist: mrs smith was dorothy arnold. She just changed her name after eloping lol

gets an ad for nancy drew they talk about it aight then

6:05 missed pun: "'s time to Nancy Draw some conclusions of our own."

Fragrance scent called Its Ya Boi

hot searing teens!!

The 1910s era Gossip Girl series should be called Gibson Girl lmao (also 100% Would Watch That)

Must not have been impossible, it happened, lol.


Ok, can we talk about how the new Nancy drew show is literally just Riverdale with a different name? I mean she’s literally just the main character with red hair instead of blonde

Socialites be like: *Hold up, lemme disappear*

I literally got an ad for the Nancy Drew show, wow

"There is going to be 10 more seasons of keeping up with the KardaSHANEs "

10:46, "hOw ArE tHeY gONnA kNoW?" well ... they could check your fingerprint but idk

Who was the new benefactor to the parents will?

please do the Alcasser murders in Spain! absolute crazy mystery

" nobody knew about any secret marriage or eloping" why would her friends or family know about something that is inherently SECRET BY DEFINITION!?? Duhhhrr

dude on the left looks high AF in the intro lol

"This story does not become humourous or romantic" it's alright that's what we've got you two for!

I carry cash

Honestly kind of surprised no one thought she got abducted by aliens

Getty Images = outrageous price gouging! FYI

10:50 Shane....DNA records...

Have a little respect.

Who wouldn’t be alarmed if a frequent went missing? Regardless of age.

Omg. Didn’t know you guys were still uploading. I missed you!!!! Also Shane’s a demon just sayin.

Can’t wait for the new season of keeping up with the karda-shane-uns

She literally just could’ve been killed and buried. I mean it was 1910

The unsolved disappearance, of Judy wardrip.

I had an Antarctica phase like a year ago!! I still wanna go live there for a little while!!!! I think I keep getting recycled, hand-me-down brain cells from Shane

4:17 as an 18 year-old I feel *oFfEnDeD*

when is season four of true crime releasing?

So they talked to every FRIEND OF DOROTHY?

Sky Crime and BuzzFeed Unsolved should do a collab and have all the series episodes on TV!!

Chipmunk noises!!!! XD XD

Hey boys heres a sugestion. The mistery of mary roget from edgar a. Poe its actually based from a real crime. What a bout a video on that?

I would watch the heck out of vintage gossip girl Someone please make it

These people remind me of Rhett & Link

Look at that face 0:46

I would love to here what you guys think of the disappearance of Barbara Newhall Follett

I love my sleepytime gown

Writing her out of the will, if it was published might have been in an attempt to get her to return home. Money and family honour meant a lot back then

I really liked this series partly because it was so apolitical. The "donate to Planned Parenthood" comment was unfortunate.

The Ghoul Boys are back!!!!

Shane: donate to planned parenthood!!!

Nancy was a real person?

Do you think The Marvel Cinematic Universe have their own Buzz feed Unsolved series? Like.... BuzzFeed Unsolved: The Disappearance of Peter Quill Shane: It's Probably aliens Ryan: Aliens are not real

the karshanes id watch it

Who got an ad of Nancy Drew?

Who else got a Nancy Drew ad

Have you guys considered looking into the Colonial Parkway Murders?

Jonah Jamison makes when he gets info on Spiderman: 9:45

What if her brother had her killed so he didn't have to split the inheritance?!

you should do one on the beaumont children from australia

“i’d like someone to give me a lot of money for doing nothing” isn’t that what he does?? he doesn’t believe in ghosts

But isn’t it unusual that she told her mom not to come w/ her? Idk but if I was going dress shopping I would’ve been like sure come along

I know it isn't a cheerful topic, but why do you never cover the suicide theories in cases? Van Gogh for sure killed himself, Natalie Wood possibly did, and most of Dorothy Arnold's family and friends believe she committed suicide.


Ryan: "That we pissed off a vanished so much that they un-vanished themselves? Shane: Like if D.B. Cooper was like "You assholes, listen." Ryan Imitating Cooper: "I saw what you said about me getting speared by a pine tree." *D.B Cooper breaks silence to dunk on Ghoul Boys* I mean, the Watcher is probably getting angry somewhere, drinking Cola as he's furiously writing Buzzfeed a letter. "So, about those two young-blooded dorks of yours...."

Can you do the Orderud case from Norway

how much weed does Shane smoke?

you should solve the mystery behind Danielle Cohn's age

Did anyone else get the Nancy Drew add twice while watching this video?

*donate to Planned Parenthood* I love you guys so much.

"So you want to be a trust fund baby" The crazy Limelight aka me: I DONT REALLY WANNA TRUST FUND BABY!

Them looking in the camera while saying my name triggers my fight or flight

I’m Dorathy Arnold Not

watching this episode is just me getting whiplash every time they say my name I feel like I’m on a video call with them but they can’t hear me

That’s the guarantee

I’m a trust fund baby, you can trust me

For postmortem: could you guys make unsolved and ruining history podcasts? I love them so much and I listen to them while I'm at work or driving. Also bring back ruining history!! Like actually, don't just read it and ignore it

I clicked on this video and the Nancy drew ad came on

I am Dorothy

Private dicks??? Anyone else hear that

She had one to liverpool from new york? She probably came here then, i know a family named arnold maybe its them

DO KURT COBIAN’S MURDER!!! btw love you guys ❤️

5:53 making me emotional

“Keeping up with the Karda-Shanes”



Lotta quiche, big whoops.

hi im dorothy

There is an unsolved murder in Antartica maybe The Buzz could send you guys there

But if only Mr. Beast could do his slow clap, at the end of this video.

“donate to planned parenthood” i love you guys

Hey it’s Dorothy doing well in Indiana

They need an actual tv show

Buzzfeed unsolved is literally one of the only thing I watch from Buzzfeed. Keep it coming and never go on air because it won’t be as good & juicy.

There was a Nancy Drew ad right before the vid started for me

"I don't really carry cash anymore." "Who does?" Me: People who make tips.

When is next episode coming?

I'm an arnold and I remember a arnold named dorothy.....but in Victoria bc

damnit, it wasn't until 21:21 I noticed that face through the window to the upper left behind Shane! Made me jump thinking there was someone just standing there

Gosh I love you guys.

Shane is glasses is just kinda yknow *Wack*

finally back to ya guys show

I mean, she could have died having the abortion, and when the P.Is found out, the parents paid to have it covered up, to avoid being shamed.

Think of it this way if you kidnap a socialite...wouldn't you ransom her off...even after you kill her

I am Dorothy Arnold

Can you guys do one on the Wonderland murders I'd love to hear you're take on it!

Oh, that’s a lovely scent! What is that? [CHIPMUNK NOISE] Ok! Well I’ll see you later!

My theory is that Dorothy was planning a trip for freedom, her mother had asked if she could come but Dorothy said No in a bratty way, most likely meaning she wanted to be treated like a adult. So she wanted to move, as her history had shown, she booked a ship and on her way bought chocolates and a book for the ride to Europe. She had sent the postcard to her father but he was in disbelief. George Griscom had later heard about her move and decided to go on vacation to Europe, where they probably got secretly married

0:07 why is Shane staring into my soul he is freaking me out

6:08 Why is that one shot of the scene from nancy drew, the scariest thing we have seen on any episode of unsolved

Keeping up with the Kardashane’s killed me

The family Is very suspicious

shane is disgustingly proud of that pun (11:04)

i love how i got a nancy drew ad before this video

Hi, this is Dorothy Arnold.

19:32 WOW we Stan these men

I think she contacted her parents.. and whatever it was they decided it was too shameful.... Maybe tshe had a baby(got pregnant by that 40 yr old) and was keeping the baby... that being shameful she was never allowed to resurface, never expected to come back or turn up for there wills, they might have sent her some money.... maybe she lived a long life happily with her child, out of the spotlight. ☺️

Wanna hear something funny? My nic name for my little brother is "lil Lui"

mom im scared.

Ryan, Shane isn’t scared of snow like you are. He grew up in the Midwest, we know snow.

Not even 2mins in and I’m already failing to suppress my giggles (I’m at work) !!! God dang I missed your videos & banter! Please please make more of these crime ones!! I stopped watching the supernatural ones because they just don’t Intrest me but omg how I have missed these true crime masterpieces!! Big love from NZ

Do the murder of Seth Rich please

guys you should take a pc somewhere and ask them to type what they want to say

of course i get a Nancy Drew ad as I’m watching this

Right before this video I got an ad about the movie Nacy Drew did anyone else got that ad too?

Noel Miller and Cody Ko look different

Okay so what If the parents found out she did elope and they hired someone to kill her so that’s why they took her off their will and told police to stop searching for her

Xoxo, Gossip girl

dorothy: ight ima tell you when i find the perfect dress i guess she never found the one she wanted ‾\_(ツ)_/‾



Wow was not expecting Shane to just throw out Sioux Falls as an example no one ever talks about South Dakota

I still think you guys should cover either Tammy Lynn Leppert, an extra in the 1983 Scarface who went missing after filming, or the Max Headroom Incident, one of the most well known TV hijackings ever pulled.

Can someone tell them to leave buzzfeed they would be so much better if they just left the try guys left and their so much more successful

probably sacrificed and eaten by the diabolical elites.

the only sensible people at buzzfeed

"little stuart?" "no, stuart little" "oh, the mouse"

why’d ryan say that dorothy would be 127?

Wow though.



aw man I don’t want an edgy Nancy drew smh >:/ that’s like making an edgy murder she wrote lmao

Oh goodness. I never thought I would see the day. I never did find the dress I was looking for

Ryan: I don’t even have 750 dollars in my bank Me@ buzzfeed: can you pay them more?

Do Kayla Berg

Ryan: "lets think like nancy drew and Nancy draw up some theorys" Me: CAnt decide on laughing or cringing so does both simultaneously

"donate to planed parenthood"

I am Dorothy wait is this thing on wait what am i ........

Did anyone realize that head in the window at 14:26

Late comment I know but you guys make serious murders and kidnappings and actual scary things hilarious. another thing you guys should talk about is jack the ripper/leather apron if you can gather info. on it

Anyone else looking for someone named Dorothy Arnold in the comments?


When they were talking about Nancy I got an ad about Nancy show

they made Dortheys disappearance know to the public on my birthday (not exactly cause I was born on January 25, 2007)

Dorthy told her parents she wanted to marry gorge, they got mad and killed her. That’s why it took so long to start the investigation and why they took her out of the will so quickly

One of my old teachers has the last name Arnold and she’s one of the oldest teachers in the school— weLp, i guess this is the only buzzfeed unsolved ep that may be solved

Bruh she dissappeared on my birthday

Yeah it’s that last one.

Can you two please do Nora? (The severly autistic girl)

My theory is that the parents found out what really happened to Dorothy (most likely that she eloped), and they were so upset they called off the investigation, told everyone she died and wrote her out of the will. #postmortem

Before the video it was a Nancy ad

The fact that I got a Nancy Drew ad before this is weird.

Do the murder in the bayou strange and unsolved murders

What if one of Dorathy’s sibilings wanted more money in the will so kidnapped her and killed her then pressured the father to cut her out of the will.


You should do the Paul McCartney theory

*happiness noise* ~happiness movement~

Can you guys please do Harold Holt?, He was the Australian PM for christs sake- one day he went into the ocean... and was never seen again. Pleeease cover Harold Holt!

Maybe she did have an abortion, the dad found out, got angry, kidnapped her to teach her a lesson or something, locked her up up near the West Point home, where she dies, gets Little Louis and others to bury her. After that, he writes her out of the will because he can't deal with a daughter who made her own choices. WHO THINKS?

Maybe don't donate to Planned Parenthood, an organisation that kills babies

I would like to see old case finally be solve...



I have a friend with his last name Arnold (and yes I know people can have the same last name I just think it’s funny because he hates this stuff

How did I miss this video lol?

Bruh. Is it me or does Shane have way more emotion that before?

I’m just surprised he said Sioux Falls! Shout out to SD!

Why was $300 in 1910 only $750 in our money now, but $1000 in 1910 is $26,000???

Next up on UNSOLVED....kaspar hauser or the servant girl annihilator

I got a Nancy Drew AD right before this video.


The only show from BuzzFeed I actually want to watch.

Other news